Add Question

Question Title

Would you rather...

Blue Option
Red Option
 

 

Back to top

Would you rather...

Be deaf

Be Amish

Would you rather...

0%
191,967 agree
Be deaf
0%
207,012 disagree
Be Amish

Living life

added by koeniginator
Loading Comments…
Unmoderated: This question has not been reviewed by You Rather moderators. Content may be misformatted, offensive or inappropriate in nature.

96 comments

  • 82

    jazzhands

    1 year ago

    Nothing says I have to be a loyal Amish. Just can't show my neighbors my iPod, otherwise I'll get pitchfork'd to the face for being a witch.

    • 17

      AkshaySauce

      10 months ago

      Just get cochlear implants, because hey, I'm not Amish.

    • 11

      Forehead58

      9 months ago

      To both of you, that defeats the purpose of the question. If you're deaf, you're stuck with it. If you're Amish, you live an Amish lifestyle.

    • 1

      Minkzx

      9 months ago

      I know plenty of Amish people with technology Just not in the house! I know Amish people that play the radio in their buggys

    • 7

      theTexan

      8 months ago

      Forehead58 Loopholes are what make this game fun so screw off.

    • 3

      Joshua Brown

      7 months ago

      Amish people aren't that outdated(i mean they don't use technology but I don't think they'd execute you either you dumbass)

    • 4

      Pinkstreaks

      7 months ago

      I'm young enough to be able to only be Amish for a few years and then get my year off/option to go to the outside world, so I could leave and still have my hearing. Sorted.

    • 0

      iamawesomecat

      5 months ago

      Dude of I were dead I'd learn sign language and also I'd just be Amish after that

    • 0

      I'd rather

      4 months ago

      Those guys will chase you if you try to escape, there mad.

    • 0

      Piers Geenty

      3 months ago

      i agree with you sir

    • 0

      lennard janssens

      2 months ago

      you made me come back on my decision

    • 0

      Zaltys

      2 months ago

      But... you wouldn't be a real amish then. Just someone who pretends to be one. Not good enough loophole for this choice.

  • 16

    Leander Stalfos Yard

    1 year ago

    damn. Really, people? screw being amish.

    • 7

      suck my titty

      1 year ago

      screw being deaf!

    • 1

      Pinkie Pie

      10 months ago

      Amish people aren't bad, being one just means no cars or electricity in PERSONAL life, so an Amish person could be a web designer at work, but would have to walk/bike/horse (pony hehe) there instead of driving, and not bring your work home with you

    • 2

      Vanquix

      9 months ago

      maybe, but id rather just get cochlear implants and hear again. and i can get them because im not amish so i can use technology for personal reasons.

    • 1

      alisox

      6 months ago

      @Pinkie Pie - Um...I'm pretty sure the Amish believe technology interferes with a relationship with God and view it as a sin so they wouldn't use any at all anywhere. Southern Maryland has the highest Amish population outside of Pennsylvania and I see lots of them when I visit family. That's just not how it works.

  • 5

    Mikhail Equality Har

    10 months ago

    Pretty sure the Amish would kill me for being gay. I can always learn sign language, so...

  • 3

    jack notman

    10 months ago

    being amish you get the choice to leave the religion and a year to experience outside life.

    • 2

      Martin

      10 months ago

      Dude that would suck, you'd have so much culture shock it wouldn't even be funny. Plus after you have to go back to being Amish.

  • 3

    SAUCY SCOTSMAN

    11 months ago

    You can just leave whenever... Deafness is usually permanent.

    • 0

      T.P.N

      3 months ago

      and thats why i chose Amish.

  • 2

    Pimpsta

    9 months ago

    That was rough...

  • 2

    nashcali22

    1 year ago

    this one is hard

  • 1

    Harley Quinn

    4 months ago

    It doesn't say you have to stay Amish

  • 1

    ScrewYou

    6 months ago

    You could just leave the Amish place.

    • 0

      alisox

      6 months ago

      Hooray for Rumspringa!

    • 0

      alisox

      6 months ago

      But in all seriousness, I think the question means *being* Amish permanently, not for a little while and changing your mind. I don't get why people look for loopholes in these questions.

  • 0

    tegix62

    3 weeks ago

    DEAF PLEASE :L

  • 1

    CarsonXIII

    8 months ago

    At 16 you have the choice to leave your Amish ways and live in the city with technology and things as such. It's called Rumspringa.

  • 1

    Pedrodarigan

    8 months ago

    Priorities at it's finest

  • 1

    SteveKobbs

    9 months ago

    You can fix being deaf. Bilateral Cochlear Implants.

  • 1

    Hannah

    9 months ago

    I can still get on the internet.

  • 1

    Hime Takamura

    10 months ago

    they have technology today to restore hearing in deaf people, if only a little.

  • 1

    Bob

    10 months ago

    if you're deaf you're just in need of another language...being amish means you are nucking futts

  • 1

    Luke Woolley

    10 months ago

    Wow, people have messed up priorities.

    • 4

      Brian Sherman

      10 months ago

      Well look who I found

    • 1

      Vanquix

      9 months ago

      Actually, YOU have screwed up priorities if youd rather choose a religion which you may or may not truly believe in just to be able to hear, which you can get implants (cochlear implants) for anyways.

  • 1

    Dom Kain

    10 months ago

    rumspring a

  • 0

    Alex Torres

    1 month ago

    rather not hear things than live without my pc

  • 0

    Daggag21

    2 months ago

    Hearing aid

  • 0

    Emilia

    2 months ago

    I like this question. Give up the ability to hear stupidity or give up the ability to be happy...hmm......

  • 0

    Daniel Danjah Andersson

    2 months ago

    My God people really dislike the Amish, don't they

  • 0

    katie

    2 months ago

    I am fluent in sign language, and Deaf culture is beautiful. I don't know anything about being Amish.

  • 0

    Michael Finnamore

    3 months ago

    Anything's better than being amish.

  • 0

    Angelo GarcĂ­a

    3 months ago

    I know sign language already.

  • 0

    paarthurnax

    3 months ago

    i would just sin and then be shunned by them problem solved

  • 0

    Molly

    4 months ago

    At least I have the Internet.

  • 0

    iTzAwesomsauce

    4 months ago

    Being Amish would fucking suck ass

  • 0

    Ryuu

    4 months ago

    1. Become Amish 2. Convert 3. Profit

  • 0

    Troy

    4 months ago

    wtf? what kind of question is this?

  • 0

    ThatGuySam

    4 months ago

    I didn't hear the question.

  • 0

    joe

    4 months ago

    WHAT DID YOU SAY?! I CANT HEAR YOU WHILE I'M POSTING A COMMENT!

  • 0

    sinidj

    5 months ago

    Doesn't say i'd have to stay Amish

  • 0

    brittney

    5 months ago

    whats amish

  • 0

    Jamison Oslund

    5 months ago

    Amish? Ew. I'm already deaf :)

  • 0

    GhostBro92

    5 months ago

    Amish people are pretty bad ass.

  • 0

    alisox

    6 months ago

    One of my big fears is going deaf. I hate when I can't hear what's going on around me. I never listen to music with both ears of headphones because I'm afraid I won't hear something around me.

  • 0

    Aaro Kirss

    6 months ago

    Not giving in to the loophole, I'd rather be deaf then blind to the wonders of technology as the Amish are.

    • 1

      alisox

      6 months ago

      Most Amish adults know about technology, they aren't "blind" to it. They choose not to have it in their lives which I actually respect.

  • 0

    Quill Skidmore

    6 months ago

    I know ASL

  • 0

    immabaus4774

    7 months ago

    I can read lips anyways

  • 0

    Liam

    7 months ago

    im scared of being amish honestly

  • 0

    Edward Williams

    7 months ago

    Wish I didn't vote that. Amish people are practically confined to their community... constantly surrounded by happy-clapping builder Christians who hate tech would be more debilitating than deafness

  • 0

    Wigglenuts

    7 months ago

    Let's see, young beautiful wife, check! Plot of land, check! Near Utopian community, check! Beautiful house and barn, check! Clean food, check! ... this isn't even a contest.

  • 0

    Max

    8 months ago

    Amish are aloud to leave and choose if they want to come back or not...I already know my choice.

  • 0

    gardenGnostic

    8 months ago

    I know sign language. Hahaha.

  • 0

    Cyrus233

    8 months ago

    Wow, this is rude.

  • 0

    Amanda Lynn Hehl

    8 months ago

    I know sign language~

  • 0

    Yuiopy

    8 months ago

    You can stop being Amish.

  • 0

    Jishushika White

    8 months ago

    Amish people don't know what ANIME is. That's a BIG problem.

  • 0

    Cammie

    9 months ago

    What's wrong with being deaf? I'd LOVE to be part of the deaf community.

Load More

Tip: Use the arrow keys to navigate between questions.

Recently Answered

You Rather Mobile

You Rather is available for free on iOS and Android. You're welcome.

For iOS For Android