Add Question

Question Title

Would you rather...

Blue Option
Red Option
 

 

Back to top

Would you rather...

Be in a car accident that kills only you

Be responsible for a car accident where you live but your five closest friends and family die

Would you rather...

0%
412,547 agree
Be in a car accident that kills only you
0%
47,535 disagree
Be responsible for a car accident where you live but your five closest friends and family die

Car Accident

added by Brian
Loading Comments…
Unmoderated: This question has not been reviewed by You Rather moderators. Content may be misformatted, offensive or inappropriate in nature.

187 comments

  • 78

    babalooskies

    3 years ago

    86% would rather die than watch their five closest friends die? i find that hard to believe

    • 159

      nashcali22

      1 year ago

      Are you serious? You would want to live with the guilt of knowing you killed the five people you care about most?

    • 84

      babalooskies

      1 year ago

      of course! its easy to say "i'd rather die" by clicking a button on a website. But if the actual situation presented itself, 99% of you would rather live.

    • 43

      JanCarlo

      1 year ago

      I agree, that's absolute bullshit. I chose the truth and picked the minority because I'm a dick, but I admit it.

    • 17

      La-a

      1 year ago

      92%

    • 27

      SageOfSixPaths

      10 months ago

      Its not so much the guilt im worried about, but the depression i would go through after that car crash, and it doesnt say that u dont get injured. Maybe you are paralyzed!

    • 40

      Jo Kristoffer

      9 months ago

      I don't really think I'd give a fuck about being dead if I was dead.

    • 25

      ZmanElete

      9 months ago

      I BELIEVE IN LIFE AFTER DEATH BITCHES!

    • 9

      CoreyH

      9 months ago

      @ZmanElete no.

    • 1

      bjshnog

      9 months ago

      That actually sounds stupid.

    • 3

      Mackenzee Hemming

      9 months ago

      id be dead either way

    • 6

      Haider

      8 months ago

      it's changed now... it's 90% for blue and 10% for red... mmhhmm.

    • 8

      Amon

      8 months ago

      I don't care much for living anyway.

    • 7

      ChimpGoggles

      8 months ago

      I have been in situations were I put myself in danger to save someone I cared about. If you really care about someone, you will want to protect them. If not, you are either A) a coward, B) unable to react C) bent on self preservation (which is understandable) of D) didn't care about them that much in the first place.

    • 1

      Dominic

      8 months ago

      zman! the afterdeath! lol! i like that! but seriously, my five closest friends include my brothers, and its something ive thought about before, i would die for them in a heartbeat!

    • 3

      Yabucek

      8 months ago

      Now it's 90%. + you are RESPONSIBLE for the accident

    • 2

      DaftRaven

      7 months ago

      Doesn't say I am in the hospital fighting for my life and die, so death would be quick and easy. Even though this was posted two years ago, I just want to put in my two cents!

    • 2

      Claire Perry

      7 months ago

      I didn't lie with my decision. Yes, maybe some did lie to feel like they were caring people but I don't value life as much as most. If I did choose to live, I'd be wrapped in guilt, and my life would be somewhat ruined anyway.

    • 2

      Nadja

      7 months ago

      No. I'd choose death. I'm not afraid of it, if it means that everyone I love is safe.

    • 0

      Alvo Razzi

      6 months ago

      You're afraid of death? You're a pussy. Have the Japanese not taught us anything? What about the Celts? or our proud soldiers huh? You're a coward and should be forced to die.

    • 0

      Sameog

      6 months ago

      Well, I only have those five people (unpopular)

    • 0

      Francis Charpentier

      6 months ago

      OP is an asshole

    • 3

      Kendall Walls

      6 months ago

      Its not even a dick move its just being truthful with yourself and I'm a new driver so most likely I didn't even do it on purpose

    • 0

      Plutters

      5 months ago

      babalooskies-Well known psychiatrist.

    • 1

      illyssa

      5 months ago

      No thanks, In reality I would rather die than have five closest people die..there is such thing as selflessness and when it comes to people I care about I would rather sacrifice myself.

    • 0

      JCF

      4 months ago

      @babalooskies youre right.....its 90

    • 0

      Idiot detector

      4 months ago

      *beep* beep* *BEEP* *BEEEEEEEP* *OVERLOAD!* *SELF DESTRUCTING!* *BOOM*

    • 0

      k6ka

      2 months ago

      the torture that you would face after killing your close friends and family would probably cause you to commit suicide. or go crazy and be shut up in an asylum.

    • 0

      XxxxBlack.Veil.BridesxxxX

      2 months ago

      whats wrong with you? no really..

    • 0

      Vin Shaw

      1 month ago

      90% aaannnddd it is higher

    • 0

      thebossyo

      1 month ago

      You only say that because u probably dot have any friends

    • 0

      halo66333

      1 month ago

      Babalookies u are a pig

    • 0

      Brownie Taylor

      3 weeks ago

      Its better for one to die but not 5

    • 0

      Ang

      2 weeks ago

      Sacrifice.

    • 0

      flozzy

      1 week ago

      suicidal sooo yea...

    • 0

      volcanor

      1 week ago

      GO PURPLE TEAM!!!!!!!

    • 1

      Leon Yiffy Mara

      1 day ago

      Or you could just accept the fact that not everyone is a self-centered douche like yourself...

  • 14

    Mandi

    2 years ago

    Assuming it were sudden? I doubt I'd mind. Whereas the alternative would stick with you for a lifetime. Pick the 5 people you love the most... Now imagine them gone forever. No thanks.

    • 4

      Matthew Marks

      9 months ago

      ..You would be dead. You would be unable to care or think. Call me selfish but i would rather live than die.It may be my fault but i think i would get over it. Guilt may be heavy, but i would get through it.

    • 2

      bjshnog

      9 months ago

      @Matthew Marks It's not just the guilt but the fact that the five closest people to you (I assume it means emotionally) would die and be gone forever. It could be your wife, kid, 2 best friends and mother. I wouldn't be ab

    • 3

      bjshnog

      9 months ago

      Damn arrow keys... -_- I wouldn't be able to live with the guilt or the fact that almost everyone I care about is gone forever.

  • 12

    dalahast

    1 year ago

    Haah, haah, haah, haah, stayin' alive.

    • 2

      ilovethedoctor77

      4 months ago

      okay, although I disagree with that because you're responsible for the death of your family, THAT WAS HILARIOUS.

    • 0

      jakereeno

      1 month ago

      I never meant to like you're comment because it wasn't funny so don't get your hopes up

  • 9

    iamdrebbits

    2 years ago

    it's called guilt. I cannot live with it.

  • 7

    Rebecca Kim

    9 months ago

    I've never really cared to live much longer into an old age. I'm happy to go whenever it suits the world.

  • 7

    Kritz29

    1 year ago

    Survivor's Guilt. Will probably end in suicide anyway.

  • 4

    DarklordTheo

    1 year ago

    Trying to figure out how I would even try to get 5 more people in my smallsmobile. Suppose 2 could fit in the trunk...

  • 3

    caffinatedpeach

    8 months ago

    Everyone who picked red is doubting us blues? Well I don't know about the rest of ya, but if my friends and family were dead, I'd see little point of living and probably kill myself anyways.

  • 2

    faithlikestacos

    5 months ago

    assuming i didn't have to make the choice i would be fine, i just don't want to live knowing that i could've saved 5 people

  • 2

    faithlikestacos

    5 months ago

    37,000+ people are really selfish.

  • 3

    Dreamkiller

    2 years ago

    What kind of heartless bastard votes the other way? If it were five friends, maybe there's a very slight chance I'd pick it, but five family/friends? No way.

  • 2

    lakersfan24

    5 months ago

    How long does it normally take them to review a question

  • 2

    Ryan Porter

    7 months ago

    Anyone who picked red is a douche

  • 2

    Kamille Blackwood

    8 months ago

    Assuming my sister would be in the car, I'd rather die than live without her. So yeah.

  • 1

    lk5t

    2 months ago

    I would never want that for anybody....

  • 2

    Emily

    9 months ago

    I would die any day for 5 of my closest friends/ family members

  • 1

    Divinity

    2 months ago

    ill move on :D

  • 2

    vsudyvyevf

    1 year ago

    Survivor's guilt. People have killed themselves because of it

  • 2

    lexi

    1 year ago

    i could hardly deal with my family and friends dying, but then if i was responsible.id probably kill myself anyway the guilt and pain would be unbearable

  • 2

    horsedickdotmpeg

    1 year ago

    I am a horrible person

  • 2

    SnazziestPants

    2 years ago

    This is so easy. I'd rather have survivors guilt than be responsible for anyone's death.

  • 2

    b1tchf4ce

    3 years ago

    Assuming their parent's wouldn't sue, im with you!

    • 0

      Rosa Maria Madanços

      8 months ago

      that was the most horrible insensitive and selfish statement i have ever heard but...hahahahahahahaha LMAO

  • 1

    ilovethedoctor77

    4 months ago

    Okay, what person wants to watch their 5 closest friends and family die?

  • 1

    feuchter_furz

    4 months ago

    I would kill myself if I was responsible for the death of my closest ones.

  • 1

    You Rather

    5 months ago

    I don't know about you guys... But I wanna live...

  • 1

    meike

    5 months ago

    I couldn't live with the guilt..

  • 1

    alisox

    5 months ago

    I didn't want my license for a long time because of a story my dad told me. He was in an accident and when he went to check on the driver of the other car, she started screaming hysterically "My baby is dead, my baby is dead!" Well her screaming woke the baby up but I would never want to live with the guilt of killing anyone, friend, family, or stranger.

  • 1

    Okan Koç

    5 months ago

    If it were random people, I wouldve chosen my life over theirs but since it's people i love, i couldn't do it

  • 1

    KamJam

    5 months ago

    I'd rather be happier dead than without loved ones.

  • 1

    Eloise Natalie Neumann

    5 months ago

    Living with the guilt wouldn't be worth living...

  • 1

    Erika Rose Prince

    5 months ago

    Honestly... I would rather die than kill friends and family. I am not scared of death and do frequently think about my own.

  • 1

    Unicyclist

    6 months ago

    Seeing other people die is sad, but the most important life is your own

  • 0

    ThePorkyJesusKing

    2 weeks ago

    I don't like most of them anyway!

  • 0

    Jake

    2 weeks ago

    90% would rather die than watch their five closest friends die? Come on guys! You can find other people!

  • 0

    greengutl

    2 weeks ago

    The second one is actually my worst fear

  • 0

    Max

    2 weeks ago

    46,718 people are selfish and careless assholes

  • 0

    SAHeat

    3 weeks ago

    My cousin died at the age of 25 due to a drunk driving accident caused by his drunk friend. I feel more sorry for the driver because he is constantly having to be sedated to stop from having serious health issues. I still am sad for my cousin but I feel terrible for his friend. And yeah whats the point, I don't really fear death.

  • 0

    Desmond

    3 weeks ago

    Could never live to know I was the reason for the death of my loved ones

  • 0

    The Ascendant

    3 weeks ago

    i like me better

  • 1

    Nöûdà

    8 months ago

    Yeah well it would cause a lot of pain to ppl that care abt me !! so IN UR FACES !! they always say they'd rather i'd die !! so careful what u wish for !! lol :p

  • 0

    myforce2001

    3 weeks ago

    90% of human beings are epic

  • 0

    Ro Davis

    3 weeks ago

    I'm guessing most of the red answers don't have children. I would gladly give my life for my kids if needed. I have told them if I ever die while saving them know that I died happy.

  • 1

    luke

    9 months ago

    One of these questions where there are people that lie and try to make themselves look good

    • 2

      bjshnog

      9 months ago

      As if you wouldn't care about everyone you care about dying because of you?

  • 1

    OmegaApple

    9 months ago

    id rather live

  • 1

    DooDooButter

    9 months ago

    Wait was i driving or just in the car? ... it doesnt say so i would say only me die cause without my fam and friends what would my life be

  • 0

    SunnyCrapCake

    1 month ago

    I've thought about this before, and I've decided that I would die for my Mother, but I would want to know that she could get over it, and be happy that she had me when I was alive.

  • 0

    Morano6

    1 month ago

    I would risk my life for others

  • 1

    youremistaken3

    1 year ago

    why would you choose anything other than have yourself die?

  • 1

    oliviax3alden

    1 year ago

    anyone that wouldn't choose to take their own life before the lives of everyone they love is messed up... what's left to live for if your family and friends are dead?!

  • 0

    callumT_

    1 month ago

    Obviously gotta pick you dying. Can't see your family and friends die.

Load More

Tip: Use the arrow keys to navigate between questions.

Recently Answered

  • You haven't answered any questions yet.

You Rather Mobile

You Rather is available for free on iOS and Android. You're welcome.

For iOS For Android