Add Question

Question Title

Would you rather...

Blue Option
Red Option
 

 

Back to top

Would you rather...

chop off your own arm

chop off a complete strangers arm, but they come back to kill you in 30 years

Would you rather...

0%
148,379 agree
Chop off your own arm
0%
238,865 disagree
Chop off a complete strangers arm, but they come back to kill you in 30 years

Arm Yourself

added by Squeaky Juice
Loading Comments…
Unmoderated: This question has not been reviewed by You Rather moderators. Content may be misformatted, offensive or inappropriate in nature.

184 comments

  • 129

    Mike Loranger

    1 year ago

    Easy choice!! It will be even easier to defeat him in 30 years if he only has one arm.

    • 16

      jordan

      1 year ago

      True but it might be given that they will kill u

    • 17

      Mike

      10 months ago

      the question says he kills you

    • 90

      OMGwhee

      9 months ago

      Actually it just says he comes back to kill you in 30 years. Whether he successfully does it or not, is another thing

    • 18

      midori

      4 months ago

      just cut an old person's arm, he will die in 30 years

    • 8

      Dudugs

      3 months ago

      Cut a 50 year old arm. Add 30 and you fight a 80 with one arm

    • 2

      MrHotWaffles

      3 months ago

      Oh gods, that's hilarious

    • 3

      NinjaticSilver

      1 month ago

      On the other hand, re-attaching my arm is doable these days. Or...I could get a mechanical arm that fires freaking laser bombs!

    • 0

      DragonXneoN

      1 month ago

      Everything is easy if you have a decent weapon.

  • 49

    Rikujin

    1 year ago

    i think being 48 is a good lifespan

    • 61

      AkshaySauce

      9 months ago

      Don't worry, at 48 you can easily kill a one-armed vigilante. Unless he becomes The Reptile like in Spiderman. Then you're screwed.

    • 3

      David Chau

      7 months ago

      And we have two arms versus his one arm. Just gotta keep taps on time and date.

  • 22

    Greg

    1 year ago

    And in thirty years I'll be waiting.. to take the other one.

  • 17

    Scoccacola

    11 months ago

    I would kill myself after 29 years and 364 days just to be an ass.

  • 16

    pikabob

    1 year ago

    Nobody said that they will succeed.

  • 11

    Leon8455

    1 year ago

    what are they going to do with one arm?

  • 11

    Rythmbot

    1 year ago

    Actually kind of a cool story.

  • 6

    Keegan M. Lowry

    1 year ago

    I'de find a man with one arm, cut it off and watch him attempt to nibble me to death.

  • 4

    wrathseed

    9 months ago

    I would kill him first. I would know the exact date so I would plant pipe bombs around my property. After that I will also boobie-trap all of the doors and windows, by rigging them with nitro glycerin and gasoline. Then, I would invest my money into a panic room with advanced ventilation and an escape hatch, only openable from the inside. Finally, I will gather my familyarmed with assult rifles and grenades. He's not gonna take me alive!!!,. The moment he

  • 3

    Meghan

    1 year ago

    If I knew that stranger would come back to kill me in 30 years, I would be so worried and upset, always anticipating my death. Plus, I'd feel guilty. I'd rather just chop off my own arm.

    • 1

      SonicDude203

      9 months ago

      it never said he would actually kill you. wether he actually kills you is another story

  • 3

    LoyalJoker

    1 year ago

    Chop off my own. So then I could get one of those badass robotic prosthetic arms

  • 3

    mindfreakz

    1 year ago

    easy choice who would want to die with an infected arm

  • 2

    25western

    4 months ago

    Arrr! I got me hook now!

  • 1

    Kratos

    2 months ago

    I would kill him before he kills me and by that time he would be an old man with one arm xD

  • 2

    Yuiopy

    8 months ago

    I'll be ready.

  • 2

    devon

    9 months ago

    what if i chop off a really old person's arm... boom. found a loop hole

    • 1

      Fluffles

      4 months ago

      lol chop off the arm of someone who's about to die: you just gave them 30 years of extra life and saved yourself an arm. It's win-win.

  • 2

    Brdie

    1 year ago

    43? Yeah I could have a family by then!

  • 2

    canadice

    1 year ago

    127 hours...

  • 2

    Gringomiester

    1 year ago

    I could be in dead in 30 years anyway, jokes on him.

  • 1

    WeirdPedo

    3 months ago

    Men in Black 3. Bam.

  • 1

    Carlo Ferrera

    3 months ago

    'Tis but a scratch!

  • 1

    Wilbert Shermandale

    3 months ago

    Why stop at one arm? Slice all the limbs! Then dress him up like the black knight from Monty Python, and hide him somewhere no on will find him. If he survives, it will either be the coolest death ever, or hilarious. Potentially both

  • 0

    Levisdj

    1 week ago

    What if I kill him first o_O

  • 0

    Levisdj

    1 week ago

    What if I kill him first o_O

  • 1

    Benjamin Miller

    5 months ago

    Should I keep his arm as a trophy? And beat him with it later?

  • 0

    ismichi

    3 weeks ago

    They come to kill, but who knows if they'll be successful...

  • 1

    riley

    8 months ago

    depends on how old i am..... if im 60, im cool with that

  • 0

    gg470

    3 weeks ago

    Didn't say you can't kill him too!

  • 1

    Rick

    8 months ago

    Chop off an 80-years old man his arm, he will be dead in 30 years

  • 1

    PheonixGRX

    8 months ago

    Nothing says that they will kill you, just that they will try. And I think a 1 armed person wont do a good job.

  • 1

    wrathseed

    9 months ago

    opens that door we will smoke him! If he makes it that is...

  • 1

    TheOnionCat

    10 months ago

    Honestly, if I chopped the arm off a stranger, I'd live in terror. Or I'd forget about it. ....idk

  • 1

    Dalton Housenick

    10 months ago

    Thats like saying would you rather chop your arm off and survive...or get murdered 30 years from now...

  • 0

    Taylor Sitterson

    1 month ago

    If you cut off your own arm you can just reattach it so... If you reattach it you don't die in 30 years thus being able to live longer so suck that 62%

  • 0

    Holly Hoffman

    1 month ago

    ill be 50 by the time he comes back. good'nuff.

  • 0

    Gohon

    1 month ago

    ....witness protection program... maybe

  • 0

    Guardian

    1 month ago

    I'll be prepare (put sun glasses on)

  • 0

    Jonathan Harket Mirus

    1 month ago

    I Will be Ready -.-

  • 0

    MyOpinionIsRight

    1 month ago

    I would destroy that one-armed old man

  • 0

    Eric Page

    1 month ago

    when he comes back in 30 years I will chop off his other arm and then shoot him (I have a machete as well as a beretta and I know how to use them)

  • 0

    chelsee

    1 month ago

    or yeah just cut off a strangers arm when hes already super old lol

  • 0

    chelsee

    1 month ago

    chop off the strangers arm when you are like 70. then when he tries to kill you in 30 years youll already be dead. well unless youre like my great grandma, who died at age 98.

  • 0

    SparoTheSpider

    1 month ago

    Says he comes back to kill you, never says he succeeds

  • 0

    Jason Paul

    2 months ago

    Robot arm nuff said.....

  • 0

    nigg

    2 months ago

    id chop off his other arm and both his legs then call it a draw

  • 0

    tristan jensen

    2 months ago

    That's strait out of Men in Black 3. By the way, it was 40.

  • 0

    Cj Martin

    2 months ago

    I can just see Anderson from Hellsing coming to kill me now

  • 0

    jumpingoffthewalls

    2 months ago

    My reasoning is that If I chop off my own arm I can get a sweet robot arm - and then kill the complete stranger if I wanted to.

  • 0

    kikou-shou

    2 months ago

    Then become a cyborg!

  • 0

    Sebastian

    2 months ago

    Looper much?

Load More

Tip: Use the arrow keys to navigate between questions.

Recently Answered

  • You haven't answered any questions yet.

You Rather Mobile

You Rather is available for free on iOS and Android. You're welcome.

For iOS For Android