Add Question

Question Title

Would you rather...

Blue Option
Red Option
 

 

Back to top

Would you rather...

Be a Jedi

Be a Sith

Would you rather...

0%
331,990 agree
Be a Jedi
0%
116,132 disagree
Be a Sith

Star Wars Decision

added by Jim
Loading Comments…

Can not have any redemption from long lost sons.

  • Meta Votes448,122 votes
  • Tags
Unmoderated: This question has not been reviewed by You Rather moderators. Content may be misformatted, offensive or inappropriate in nature.

206 comments

  • 119

    Brian

    3 years ago

    Um...Force Lightning?

    • 18

      Ryan

      10 months ago

      you have a point good sir...

    • 28

      Benjamin Walters

      10 months ago

      Jedi are capable of Force Lightning it is just frowned upon as anger is required to use it. Some grey-jedi are capable of this feat.

    • 26

      D'vaughn Clarke

      10 months ago

      "Remember,its not the powers you use,it's how you use them"-Luke Skywalker

    • 25

      Kendrick Smith

      10 months ago

      The Jedi, including the Jedi Council, are the most ineffective society ever.While the Sith have conquered several Galaxies. Not only that the fact there are only tho thanks to Darth Bane, has helped the Sith become pretty awesome.

    • 7

      pikle6007

      10 months ago

      instant decision

    • 21

      Magnus

      8 months ago

      UNLIMITED POWER!!!

    • 7

      Lukas Nielsen

      7 months ago

      Yeah :D as a sith, you can do whatever you want ;)

    • 1

      Meemo2

      7 months ago

      thinkin same timg

    • 3

      Niker107

      6 months ago

      Lots and lots of red comments, however blue has a bigger percentage. Also, I don't watch Star Wars anyway, but a Sith is cooler :D

    • 2

      Becky Barnes

      5 months ago

      um they die :P

    • 5

      maxwell1981

      5 months ago

      Remember in "Revenge of the Sith"? Almost all of the Jedi were exterminated.

    • 1

      Reconzile

      3 months ago

      Does it matter if the whole galaxy wants you dead, an you have hundreds of Jedi's living for that purpose?

    • 3

      Omnipotent

      2 months ago

      I had always felt my place was with the Jedi, to be a Sith would mean a galaxy of hate, constantly hunted, and always having the fear of being stabbed in the back by your "comrades". Also even if the sith at the time of your joining were to have control over the galaxy like in order 66, there still was the rebellion, which defeated them against all odds and the Jedi were reborn.

    • 1

      Shaco Clone

      1 month ago

      all i got to say is "Join the dark side, We have cookies!"

  • 25

    Kronos

    3 years ago

    Dark side is always more powerful and funnier (no rules and all)... plus they have cookiiiiies ! :p

    • 12

      Palmuu

      10 months ago

      actually dark side has rules too

    • 4

      xdpher

      9 months ago

      not really

    • 2

      Aaron

      6 months ago

      ya but you fight each other to be the only super powerful being

  • 20

    roxygirl

    1 year ago

    Come 2 the dark side... We have cookies

  • 13

    Derek

    3 years ago

    But as a Sith you can brood.

  • 12

    babalooskies

    3 years ago

    have fun as an abstinent jedi

    • 0

      Ben Ellis

      7 months ago

      Where do you think those minijedi Anakin slaughtered came from?

    • 1

      Jamie Piktel

      5 months ago

      That doctrine was abandoned after a while. Plus, there are enough badass Jedi out there that say "fuck you" to the council ways and its rules.

    • 0

      MATAEJO

      3 months ago

      That was the old order in the new order families are allowed

  • 12

    Brendan

    3 years ago

    Really you pale bastards?

  • 8

    Jim

    3 years ago

    Double Lightsabers! (Episode 1)

  • 6

    Mrgamer624

    9 months ago

    Sith. I'd prefer freedom from all the bullshit with relations of the opposite sex. I love my girlfriend

  • 6

    n1nja_nacho

    11 months ago

    LIGHTNING BOLT!

  • 7

    Zach Dunn

    3 years ago

    I think I may have to reconsider my original answer simply because of the brooding opportunities.

  • 6

    Nix

    1 year ago

    Sith are guided by emotion; dangerous as it is I would not want to live a life of contained feelings.

  • 4

    Kirin1010

    9 months ago

    What did you say to me? *force choke*

  • 4

    Denis Paluca

    9 months ago

    Join The Dark Side

  • 5

    Sam Dunn

    3 years ago

    Blue lightsabers!

    • 6

      LordMackarl

      9 months ago

      Dude, you can make lightsabers of any colour to any class. Sure, it's a bit weird, but being a Jedi doesn't mean you can't have a red lightsaber. And Sith can have lightsabers of any colour, they just take every type has a trophy.

    • 0

      Aron Karkea

      9 months ago

      Well red lightsabers are red because of a Synthetic lightsaber crystal which is a artificially created crystal that makes the lightsaber a bit stronger than those with naturally grown crystals, aka regular ones

  • 4

    RedSquirrel

    2 years ago

    I am just not emo enough to whine my way through the galaxy.

    • 3

      Ben

      9 months ago

      whine? Sith are not emo pussy fag whining 14 year olds. they are like bad ass metalhead mother fuckers with lights sabers and lightning.

  • 3

    Asher

    1 year ago

    Have you ever noticed that there is only one black guy, and only one purple lightsaber.

    • 3

      Emalee Bennett

      10 months ago

      Lando was black... Granted he wasn't a Jedi. But more than just one Jedi has the purple lightsaber. Watch the huge gift scene of Episode 2

  • 3

    Cruelparody

    1 year ago

    all the power with none of the rules or responsibilities

  • 2

    Jacob Fitzgerald

    7 months ago

    "becoming a jedi is no easy task Anikon and even if you succeed its a hard life" but being a sith is just fucking fun killin bitches and shit

  • 2

    Cricketeer

    8 months ago

    NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO i picked the wrong one

  • 2

    little man

    8 months ago

    Have you guys read the books that inspired the movies? There are WAY more books. And in them did you know Luke had one green light saber and a shorter red one?

  • 2

    Grayson Goosey Mille

    9 months ago

    I think the Jedi are more evil than the Sith. The Jedi forced the Empire to do the things it did, and other than those terrible things, the people under the Empire's reign had a good life. Not like those under the republic, constant war and strife, then being oppressed by the morals of some forgotten religion.

  • 2

    SirNarwhal

    10 months ago

    Bad guys always lose, remember?

  • 2

    VoltStar

    10 months ago

    why be a Jedi? you cant have a girl friend or merry. Also, what is really good or bad in the universe? its all about perspective.

  • 2

    theotherskywalker

    10 months ago

    apparently most people don't know the power of the dark side.

  • 2

    David Bell

    10 months ago

    sith, because i love others' demise

  • 2

    JaRadnitch

    1 year ago

    Why would you want to be a frickin' jedi?

    • 0

      SHAZAM!

      8 months ago

      To serve and protect that's the dream

  • 1

    Ralathon

    3 months ago

    The Emperor did what he did to save the galaxy from an impending invasion in which the corrupt council would be unable to prevent. The emperor knew due to how corrupt the council was it would fall leaving a power vacuum which would result in civil war and being unprepared for the invasion. Luke by doing what he did effectively doomed the galaxy.Flying spaghetti monster im nerdy.

  • 1

    Sargent@$$Face

    3 months ago

    Jedi are lame. Give in to the dark side!

  • 2

    Majornougat

    1 year ago

    dem robes, man

    • 4

      ಠ_ಠ

      9 months ago

      siths also get robes, which, in my mind, are better

  • 1

    Ashley Wiley

    3 months ago

    dude... what the hell. REALLY? come on peeps!!!

  • 1

    iMustacheUaQuestion

    3 months ago

    Idej A Eb

  • 1

    awsme267

    3 months ago

    can I get a helmet?

  • 1

    Piers Geenty

    3 months ago

    I eat Jedi scum for breakfast

  • 1

    wartpig

    3 months ago

    both cry and whine when they are not in controll. even tho their goals are EXACTLY THE SAME. the both want peace. one just uses flowers the other a cold boot. history tells us flowers get nothing done but bickering.

  • 1

    Deadnought

    3 months ago

    Red lightsaber.

  • 1

    Kody

    3 months ago

    Jedi cant have sex

  • 1

    Matej Jurišić

    5 months ago

    FOR THE REPUBLIC

  • 0

    Malicious

    2 weeks ago

    Uhh, sith are fucking badass look at Darth Revan and Malek!

  • 1

    Konstantin Askinadze

    6 months ago

    its about the feelings as a jedi you have to controll them as a sith you can let your anger flow

  • 1

    Gustavo Freitas

    8 months ago

    Jedi duhh

  • 1

    Jacob "Blitzkrieg"

    10 months ago

    Good guys > bad guys

  • 1

    Raymond Johnson

    10 months ago

    Come to the dark side. We have cookies.

  • 1

    Ryan

    10 months ago

    The Sith get cool stuff, but they all end up dying.

    • 0

      Devyn Dasilva

      2 months ago

      Actually the Sith outlived the Jedi. Though Luke was trained in the Jedi arts, he never was sworn into the order, therefore he was not a Jedi. That makes Darth Vader the last standing in both the Jedi and Sith side. (Darth Vader=Sith)

  • 1

    Ethan

    1 year ago

    Being a jedi would require a ridiculous amount of will power. I'm not required to kill anything or anyone by the sith code.

    • 0

      Scluaris

      8 months ago

      Actually, you are kinda required to kill... They believed conflict was the only way to better themselves.

  • 0

    Eden Richardson

    1 month ago

    Sith

  • 0

    CyborgKittenPoweh

    1 month ago

    jedi. think of how aweosme that would be! you could use the force on toy spiders and scare people with it :D

  • 0

    Careem Gilbert

    1 month ago

    Jedi Please

  • 0

    Omri Shoval

    1 month ago

    Sith because they have a death star

  • 0

    Omri Shoval

    1 month ago

    Sith because they have a death star

  • 0

    Samuel

    2 months ago

    even the colors match the sabers, interesting...

Load More

Tip: Sign up to see adult-rated questions.

Recently Answered

You Rather Mobile

You Rather is available for free on iOS and Android. You're welcome.

For iOS For Android