Add Question

Question Title

Would you rather...

Blue Option
Red Option
 

 

Back to top

Would you rather...

kill 5 people with a knife

shoot 10 people to death

Would you rather...

0%
134,946 agree
Kill 5 people with a knife
0%
245,331 disagree
Shoot 10 people to death

Killing spree

added by Matthew Urasaki
Loading Comments…

Assume that it will take multiple stab wounds for the person to die and that it will be a more painful way to go.

  • Meta Votes380,277 votes
  • Tags
Unmoderated: This question has not been reviewed by You Rather moderators. Content may be misformatted, offensive or inappropriate in nature.

216 comments

  • 77

    Viperxiii

    1 year ago

    apparently, people are afraid of getting their hands dirty

    • 30

      Vicci Love

      1 year ago

      I do it out of, (odd way to use it) kindness. I'd rather just be shot than stabbed. Quicker. And as the killer, I suffer less, when you stab people they cry out in pain, when you shoot people they just die.

    • 33

      setrakakan

      9 months ago

      Oh wow people 'just die' when shot? I didn't realize no one has ever survived a bullet wound before.

    • 17

      Ethan

      9 months ago

      Lots of people die from bullet wounds. A clean, decently placed shot to the head could puncture the brain, or at the least put them through a fatal coma. ... Oh god how do I know this...

    • 9

      Ryan Prasetyo-Li

      9 months ago

      Why would it take multiple stab wounds when you would be able to aim towards their neck or heart?

    • 0

      Joseph Coleman

      9 months ago

      @setrakakan in t

    • 1

      Joseph Coleman

      9 months ago

      i meant in the head

    • 14

      ZmanElete

      9 months ago

      You guys are thinking how they die im thinking how many die. To me this is a choice of how many die 5 or 10 i choose 5 almost every time

    • 5

      Devon Sait

      9 months ago

      It would be unfortunate to see 5 people go so painfully, but the pain the victims loved ones would face is what influenced my choice. When there's 10 victims the mourning is far greater - they'll all be dead in the end so it's only fair.

    • 0

      Zamekis

      8 months ago

      I find it more cruel if you stab someone...

    • 0

      Silent Guardian

      8 months ago

      @Devon Plus, whenever you shoot someone you can have HIde and Seek playing in the background. If they don't come back to life of course :D

    • 1

      Brice Johnson

      6 months ago

      It's math, 10 is more than 5.

    • 0

      Данаил Бешков

      5 months ago

      Viperxiii nah just 10 is more then 5

    • 3

      T.P.N

      5 months ago

      why cant i just kill 10 with a knife :C

    • 1

      Wolf Fang

      4 months ago

      get knife name it kindness, kill people with kindness

    • 0

      Wolf Fang

      4 months ago

      or love

    • 1

      Upbeatshadowchain

      4 months ago

      I will shoot 10 criminals to death,LOOPHOLE

    • 0

      Reconzile

      3 months ago

      @Vicci Love You should be creative enough to consider the possibility to stab them up undet their chin and right into their brain, which would kill them instantly

    • 0

      Matthew Lord

      2 months ago

      sometimes the families suffer more knowing their relative died suffering, like in the idea of the stabbing, atleast with a gun, the question giver has stated that shooting will be less painful for them, I'd rather they go with as little suffering as possible

    • 1

      tiffany

      2 months ago

      less people will die, ill go to hell anyways. take less people. they don't need to know there family suffered.

    • 0

      wartpig

      2 months ago

      wanna change vote...... Dexter...... ughhh......

    • 1

      Jamie Stewart

      2 months ago

      guns are too quick... you see, you cant savor all the little emotions...

    • 0

      Shaco Clone

      2 weeks ago

      You don't know anything till the jester rips off your eyelids so you see every murder he commits. Why do you think my name is CHAOS rearranged

  • 29

    Prophet

    1 year ago

    5 deaths is better than 10 deaths

    • 2

      deadkraze

      9 months ago

      Not if the extra 5 people are hitler, osama binladen, justin bieber, a crazed gunman who killed 50 young people (the blonde guy), and the ginger guy who killed the batman movie people

    • 0

      jojowhoa

      6 months ago

      lol that's how i justified my choice.

    • 2

      ILikesTacos

      6 months ago

      There are many people i would love to kill them in excruciating agony.

  • 9

    Greg

    1 year ago

    Easier, cleaner, more efficient.

  • 7

    Aaron5797

    8 months ago

    Do you want to know why I use a knife? Guns are too quick! You can't savor all the little...emotions. -the joker

  • 5

    Ellipsis

    9 months ago

    Just for the joy of 10. Also, population is too high anyways.

  • 5

    setrakakan

    9 months ago

    I'd rather kill 5 people than 10, simple as that.

  • 3

    ZmanElete

    9 months ago

    less deaths involved

  • 3

    D'vaughn Clarke

    9 months ago

    i'd rather not die...

  • 2

    VSpartan

    11 months ago

    People Die when they are killed... Besides, I'll be a short-term hero of justice. I'm sure killing someone for a gas station robbery is kind of harsh, but who cares?

  • 2

    wawa1474

    1 year ago

    i suck with guns (probaly accidentilly shoot 'em in the crotch)

  • 0

    Dallas Hernandez

    1 week ago

    A gun is so impersonal, You really feel you have the justification to kill someone be a man, get your hands dirty and look them in the eye and confront what your doing as the life slowly slips from there eyes

  • 0

    Andrew

    1 week ago

    Jeff the Killer anyone?

  • 0

    big115bird

    1 week ago

    I killed less people, also there are ways of doing this painlessly, get them dead drunk first and slit their throat.

  • 0

    Marcus Panico

    2 weeks ago

    The knife sounds more enjoyable.

  • 0

    Mikenna

    2 weeks ago

    I think stabbing would be more satisfying than shooting, even if it was less people, it's a longer process that can induces suffering.

  • 0

    Max

    3 weeks ago

    PEWPEWPEW MOTHERFUCKER

  • 0

    Anders Holmenlund Mi

    3 weeks ago

    sniper

  • 1

    mclovin

    8 months ago

    ask joker why he uses a knife

  • 1

    Axel Ståhlnacke

    8 months ago

    Even if thease people do suffer you spare 5 other people

  • 1

    assassin

    8 months ago

    im taking advice from the joker here.depending on who u kill, at the last moment u get to know the person in a whole new light

  • 1

    Floris

    8 months ago

    Can i also stab 10 people to death?

  • 1

    Nikola Baric

    8 months ago

    shooting is quicker and clean stabbing gets you dirty you can fell the knife going into him/her and there is a disguting noise.

  • 1

    The Joker

    8 months ago

    Do you want to know why I use a knife? You see, guns are too quick. You can't savor all of the little...emotions. In their last moments, people show you who they really are.

    • 0

      Aaron5797

      8 months ago

      Haha I posted almost the exact same thing before I even saw your comment

  • 1

    llortemageht

    8 months ago

    It didn't say who I had to kill. I would kill ten known criminals (that makes me sound like Kira)

  • 1

    deadkraze

    9 months ago

    James Bond does it all the time, and he seems pretty sucessfull. But on the other hand, if you stab 5 people, you wouldn't seem like a posh englishman with a motive, you would seem like some chavy 9 year old with a crush he is trying to impress.

  • 1

    TronCat

    9 months ago

    WHATS THE DIFFERENCE, SOMEONES GONNA DIE, JUST FOR THAT IM PUTTING TEN AND HOPEFULLY ITS ONE OF THE DUMBASSES WHO MADE THIS

  • 1

    Jacob Dittmer

    9 months ago

    shooting is more fun! and less gross.

  • 1

    Dustin Adams

    9 months ago

    "Do you want to know why I use a knife? Guns are too quick. You can't savor all the... little emotions. In... you see, in their last moments, people show you who they really are. So in a way, I know your friends better than you ever did. Would you like to know which of them were cowards?" - The Joker

  • 1

    Tanya Yemelianov

    9 months ago

    kill less people possible...

  • 1

    Callum Galloway Gree

    9 months ago

    I don't really like killing people.

  • 0

    Danny Shapovalov

    4 weeks ago

    At least I kill less people

  • 0

    Ahad Merchant

    4 weeks ago

    I WANT ME A GUN!

  • 1

    Jon

    11 months ago

    shooting people is less personal

  • 1

    Joe Brown

    1 year ago

    ether way your going to jail. so u might as well kill 10:D

    • 2

      Joel Padilla

      9 months ago

      Yes but in jail i'd rather be know as a guy who will stab ppl to death then a guy who can shoot after all there are no easily acquired guns in prison and with that rep no one would mess with you.

  • 1

    Mikaela

    1 year ago

    Johnny the Homicidal Maniac style..

  • 1

    cierra

    1 year ago

    I couldnt do it period

  • 0

    SunnyCrapCake

    1 month ago

    Can anyone actually give me evidence that a stab-wound is more painful?I'm killing less people, and they're going to be dead, they don't care about anything when they're dead.

  • 0

    Stan Ionut

    1 month ago

    These kind of questions should be banned, you sick people!

  • 0

    Bruno Pedron

    1 month ago

    It is way harder to get a gun and the bullets for it. A knife can be used multiple times and, in case you forget yours at home, there is always one at the victim's place.

  • 0

    Andrew

    1 month ago

    Killing five is better than killing ten

  • 0

    Allison Guy

    1 month ago

    How bout I kill no one? : |

  • 0

    jonadagamer

    1 month ago

    I really dont care if i have to kill the double amount if it goes ten times easier...

  • 0

    jonadagamer

    1 month ago

    I really dont care if i have to kill the double amount if it goes ten times easier...

  • 0

    jonadagamer

    1 month ago

    I really dont care if i have to kill the double amount if it goes ten times easier...

  • 0

    Jaden LeBlanc

    1 month ago

    Go for the Jugular. Or embrace your inner Joker, either one.

  • 0

    CaKeS

    1 month ago

    I have no deep insight. It'd just be more fun to shoot than stab someone.

  • 0

    Christian Kin

    1 month ago

    Puting myself in the position of a victim helped me decide here.Id rather be stabbed knowing someone else keeps on living instead of beeing shot

  • 0

    Thierry Laurendeau-Trudel

    1 month ago

    15 people with a butterknife

  • 0

    Aloerca

    1 month ago

    I just did it because of the joker bullets are too quick, you see how they feel in their least moments. You see I knew your friends better than you ever will. Would you like to know which of your friends were cowards?

  • 0

    _lost_

    1 month ago

    I mean. I already want to stab people.... Maybe more than 5

Load More

Tip: Use the arrow keys to navigate between questions.

Recently Answered

You Rather Mobile

You Rather is available for free on iOS and Android. You're welcome.

For iOS For Android