Add Question

Question Title

Would you rather...

Blue Option
Red Option
 

 

Back to top

Would you rather...

Give up Christmas

Give up your birthday

Would you rather...

0%
171,229 agree
Give up Christmas
0%
287,674 disagree
Give up your birthday

Presents

added by Rocks
Loading Comments…

If your birthday is Christmas you don't get either. If you don't celebrate Christmas, pick another gift related holiday (e.g. Hanukkah)

  • Meta Votes458,903 votes
  • Tags
Unmoderated: This question has not been reviewed by You Rather moderators. Content may be misformatted, offensive or inappropriate in nature.

297 comments

  • 62

    groovykat

    2 years ago

    my birthdays aren't amazing anyway. On Christmas, I get presents from everyone, and I get that whole Christmas-y atmosphere, with the roast dinner and everyone being happy.

    • 5

      buttholio

      9 months ago

      Yeah, I don't get stuff for birthdays.

    • 8

      Mossy

      9 months ago

      Fuck. How do I change my mind?

    • 9

      Dragonite

      8 months ago

      I don't get anything from either and I am an Atheist. I'll just give up Christmas.

    • 0

      Marshall Clowater

      7 months ago

      shit i gave my answer b4 reading ur well thought out comment. though tbh my family isnt the best for christmas time so i guess it dont matter

    • 6

      sam

      6 months ago

      i am an athiest too but who cares if everyone gets presents

    • 4

      valcorwabajak

      6 months ago

      it does not matter if your an atheist Christmas isn't about family or Jesus it's about consumerism and getting shit... oh and drinking

    • 2

      Donut

      5 months ago

      I can celebrate Three KIngs Day.

    • 0

      jhizzle244

      4 months ago

      But in Africa, Children get a meal as their christmas present

    • 1

      BrentDH

      3 months ago

      My belief: when Christianity started getting old, they invented Christmas, especially for the kids. "Sure, son. You can be an Atheist. Just don't expect anything this Christmas."

    • 1

      Blueichigo

      2 months ago

      I agree. I love being with my family. I'd take opening presents with everyone and seeing their reactions over me being the center of attention.

    • 0

      Yanda Chen

      2 months ago

      Looool. I get what I want when i want

    • 1

      Fainting Goat

      1 month ago

      Does this mean I'll never age?

    • 0

      Elijah De Pino

      1 month ago

      The spending time with friends or family on christmas.

  • 24

    horsedickdotmpeg

    1 year ago

    I'm atheist so...

    • 2

      Brdie

      1 year ago

      tuchey

    • 2

      Dudugs

      5 months ago

      birthdays suck after 10. and im a atheist and celebrate christmas

    • 0

      T.P.N

      1 month ago

      Christians stole X-mas from some other religion.

    • 0

      Moss Grande

      3 weeks ago

      Same but it's still a nice excuse to have a party with the rest of the world and be able to share presents.

  • 15

    [deleted]

    1 year ago

    birthdays suck after the age of 10 anyways

  • 14

    Jim

    3 years ago

    I needs me my Chris Kringle

  • 9

    m9rfzzy

    1 year ago

    just became jewish >> then you get gifts for 8 days. Shalom motherfluffers

    • 4

      Angryhippie47

      1 year ago

      Hey retard it says that u cant hav another religous holiday

    • 5

      SageOfSixPaths

      10 months ago

      angryhippie, are u fucking blind? "If you don't celebrate Christmas, pick another gift related holiday (e.g. Hanukkah)"

    • 2

      Advance

      7 months ago

      You morons, you can't become Jewish.

    • 0

      some random guy

      7 months ago

      Sageofsixpacks I wanna shake ur hand :D

    • 3

      some random guy

      7 months ago

      Lol sixPATHS not sixpacks lol

    • 0

      Franklin Chen

      2 months ago

      @Advance Well some atheists like me celebrate christmas, so why not hanukkah

  • 8

    youat2inthemorning

    1 year ago

    Christmas isn't the same anymore, the word christmas now means, PRESENTS.

    • 4

      Brdie

      1 year ago

      But Jesus's birthday still matters

    • 27

      youat2inthemorning

      1 year ago

      Well actually jesus was born during spring time not during winter, so yeah you got that wrong...

    • 4

      Petar Zivkovic

      1 year ago

      that's not true, it means presents and meat... plus if jesus did exist, his B-day would be somewhere in january

    • 4

      Nick

      1 year ago

      ruth, Jesus wasn't born in America >.

    • 5

      youat2inthemorning

      1 year ago

      Nick, I know jesus wasn't born in america.....

    • 10

      Nikolai T

      9 months ago

      Brdie, Jesus likely didn't exist, and he certainly wasn't divine. So, no, his (possible) birthday doesn't matter.

    • 5

      Bobby McBobz

      9 months ago

      Jesus is a fake christmas dos mean presents bitch!

    • 1

      qwert

      8 months ago

      to be fair most people don't care about it being christ's birthday it's morea time for family... WAY beater

    • 9

      youat2inthemorning

      8 months ago

      Time for families to get presents. ergo my comment

    • 1

      Anju

      8 months ago

      guys, Jesus was a real man! not divine but a man, there is historical proof. also, he was born in march.

    • 0

      youat2inthemorning

      8 months ago

      Wow anju you're late.

    • 5

      some random guy

      7 months ago

      Well while u guys debate this for the rest of ur life, I'm gonna go get layed :3

    • 3

      Jamie Piktel

      5 months ago

      *laid. Good for you.

    • 1

      tajacama

      5 months ago

      i agree. people are selfish now. i have friends that were wondering what to ask for christmas even before halloween

    • 1

      theset3

      2 months ago

      Christmas was stolen from Pagan tradition, so really you're all wrong!

    • 0

      Franklin Chen

      2 months ago

      Christmas is more of time of happiness And people like me love getting presents

  • 5

    courageoftheheart

    8 months ago

    Selfish, maybe, but my birthday is when I get the attention all on me! It's nice to get people kissing my feet once a year.

  • 5

    Jousis

    1 year ago

    Christmas, at least 5 presents. Birthday, 1 present.

  • 4

    Nicholas D Wolfwood

    9 months ago

    I'm born on December 24th...so it's not like I lose much ground.

  • 4

    jwroth12

    1 year ago

    your birthday is YOUR day... you get to do what you want

    • 0

      Brdie

      1 year ago

      But christmas is the day Jesus was born I think that is more important

    • 6

      billmok

      9 months ago

      Brdie, nobody gives a fuck about Jesus.

    • 1

      G-ette

      8 months ago

      Jesus wasn't originally born on December 25th, it was moved to that day so that other religions who celebrated on that day would be pushed aside.

  • 3

    Zombiax

    9 months ago

    Fuck Jesus

  • 3

    LOL FACE

    1 year ago

    what if your birthday is on Christmas

  • 2

    mintyfresh9080

    4 months ago

    (I only picked so I can comment) How do you give up your birthday? It will always be your birthday.

  • 1

    ionut18

    1 month ago

    P.S Cheesecakes you can skip questions by clicking the arrow buttons.(Just choose randomly for this comment)

  • 2

    sparta_the_cat

    7 months ago

    christmas is based on christianity (witch im not a part of but i celebrate anyway cause im a average person) and my birthday is my birthday

  • 2

    Sten Agnefjäll

    7 months ago

    Goodbye birthday ;(

  • 2

    Szussi

    9 months ago

    well fuck it my birthday is on christmas..

  • 2

    Brian Schwartz

    9 months ago

    Happy Hanukkah!

  • 0

    thearslan148

    1 day ago

    I'm not christian B|

  • 0

    Burgundy Panther

    2 days ago

    I don't celebrate Christmas or Hanukkah or any gift giving holiday, I've replaced Christmas with Newtonmass 'cause that's when Sir Issac Newton was born.

  • 1

    Nutbar123

    2 months ago

    I'm Muslim soo...

  • 2

    Brdie

    1 year ago

    Damn I didnt think! I thought oh my birthday is important day... Then I though "Oh thats Jesus's birthday" and already clicked :(

    • 0

      Blackjackz

      9 months ago

      @Jeremy yeah he is, he's doing my garden right now

  • 2

    jazzhands

    1 year ago

    Let's face it, my birthday doesn't mean shit, while the Holiday season is a yearly international economic boost.

  • 0

    Zoe

    4 days ago

    My birthday is on Christmas sooo............

  • 1

    Imran Meco

    4 months ago

    I'm not christian anyway!

  • 1

    Val

    4 months ago

    I am NOT giving up my birthday.. Christmas is Jesus' birthday anyway, I wouldn't give mine away for his >:(

  • 1

    ori shalhon

    4 months ago

    just so you know..there are no gifts in hanukka

  • 0

    N3VVRmiNd

    1 week ago

    I don't celebrate Christmas, but it's the most wonderful time of the year :)

  • 1

    Cagri Omer Gomec

    5 months ago

    Muslim....

  • 0

    Rezhwan Amanj

    2 weeks ago

    I'm Muslim, so I don't have Christmas already

  • 1

    Maroua Naji

    5 months ago

    meh..my birthday's the same day as christmas...so i would give up any of them and it still makes no change

  • 1

    Roflshalbowco

    6 months ago

    I'd still turn older..

  • 1

    some random guy

    7 months ago

    To all those atheists out there who comment on this, us people who have a religion respect ur beliefs so u don't have to keep saying how ur all atheist cause ur just trying to brag that ur "different" to get attention... We respect ur beliefs so respect ours please :)

    • 0

      theset3

      2 months ago

      Bullshit you respect our beliefs. I don't know where everyone else is located, but where I am, an atheist is outcast, beaten up, and even forced to pretend they're Christian due to persecution. Not to mention the impact your "leaders" have in the U.S. government, where you push your beliefs on others by keeping gay marriage illegal and trying to make abortion illegal.

  • 0

    CoolestTaco

    3 weeks ago

    i already hate christmas

  • 0

    Sinarro

    3 weeks ago

    I don't even calibrate Christmas

  • 1

    Xifihas

    8 months ago

    Christmas is a better excuse to get drunk (yeah, I'm the kind of guy who needs an excuse)

  • 1

    Cave Johnson

    8 months ago

    I get more presents at christmas, greedy fuck. I like it.

  • 1

    Vlada Vukcevic

    8 months ago

    Im Serbian -American i get 2 Christmases, the normal 25th of December, and the 7th of January. i wouldn't give up either Christmases

  • 1

    LemonBear

    8 months ago

    I'd rather have my birthday so I don't have to listen to my spoilt friends going on about how awesome their presents are

  • 1

    Amon

    8 months ago

    Last few christmases have been shitty, not special, not memorable like many others. I feel I'll never have a good one again. At least on my birth day I get appreciation more.

  • 1

    Matt700

    9 months ago

    If I picked red, would I not age ?

  • 1

    zrayz0123

    9 months ago

    Im muslim so i dont celebrate it soo ftw

  • 0

    Aftasid Emir

    3 weeks ago

    Hanukkah is not a gift related holyday

  • 1

    Jeremy

    9 months ago

    As an atheist.. birthday. I love Mythmas!

  • 1

    Ian Crawford

    9 months ago

    Fucking christmas music.

  • 1

    jon

    9 months ago

    I don't celebrate any religious holidays.

  • 1

    Rap0nmilk

    9 months ago

    never .... AGE 111111111111

    • 5

      Nikolai T

      9 months ago

      @howcouldyouvote4that? "Screw you dude" - That's really Christ-like, eh? Show me the records that prove his existence. Real ones, not ones from Christian-propaganda sites. Faith is ignorance, by the way.

  • 1

    Matthew

    9 months ago

    Snap... misclicked -_- *throws chair*

  • 1

    ewill

    9 months ago

    Christmas is family time. My birthday is just awkward.

  • 0

    SamSon

    4 weeks ago

    my finger slipped )))): fuck my birthday

Load More

Tip: Sign up to see adult-rated questions.

Recently Answered

  • You haven't answered any questions yet.

You Rather Mobile

You Rather is available for free on iOS and Android. You're welcome.

For iOS For Android