Add Question

Question Title

Would you rather...

Blue Option
Red Option
 

 

Back to top

Would you rather...

kill yourself

push a button and have a random 10,000 people die

Would you rather...

0%
190,033 agree
Kill yourself
0%
203,230 disagree
Push a button and have a random 10,000 people die

Nothing Personal

added by gingerswag
Loading Comments…

You would not be punished, but people would know what you did.

Unmoderated: This question has not been reviewed by You Rather moderators. Content may be misformatted, offensive or inappropriate in nature.

224 comments

  • 56

    helloangel

    1 year ago

    would be better for the population. to be honest i'd push it a thousand times. but not all at once. and i would save the world.

    • 15

      Gunther

      11 months ago

      That is exactly why i would push it we have to many people on the planet

    • 68

      SageOfSixPaths

      10 months ago

      The more that you push it, the bigger the chance of that random person being killed is you. Even though it is really unlikely.

    • 15

      Michael

      10 months ago

      And how would you feel if one of the people that died was your friend/family member. Besides, we're nowhere near overpopulation.

    • 30

      fred

      9 months ago

      Michael, are you retarded? because the world is reeeeally overpopulated

    • 48

      billmok

      9 months ago

      Nobody deserves to die just because our ancestors had lots of sex. Just because the world has so many people in it, 10,000 random people don't deserve to die because you think they should. Also, you're saying that Hitler saved the world by killing so many people. Hiel Hitler.

    • 54

      GENOCIDEGeorge

      9 months ago

      Awkward when you end up killing ten thousand-odd doctors and scientists, leaving the shitty YOLOists to repopulate.

    • 5

      Madison

      9 months ago

      Who post these kinds of questons?

    • 19

      Alex James Manlove

      8 months ago

      even if the world was over-populated, and I'm not saying it is, then what gives you the right to live over 10,000 people? And additionally, what if one of the people you kill would have gone on to cure cancer, or develop space travel, etc? Just food for thought.

    • 8

      rarity the unicorn

      7 months ago

      your a stupid terrible individual. By that logic we should all do our part by going a killing spree.

    • 10

      Ben Mcquarrie

      7 months ago

      would you be able to live with the fact the fact that you killed 10,000 people? could you walk up to one and put a bullet in his head? if so the your a psychopath and probably need urgent medical attention or some cat fur for you to roll around in.

    • 1

      valentinwirstadg

      6 months ago

      Then hitler saved the world to.

    • 3

      Samantha Zapata

      6 months ago

      Chance of one of those people being someone you love.

    • 0

      Giovanni Oliver

      6 months ago

      @Ben: Some people can do that, and they're not psychopaths. For example, most soldiers aren't, yet they live with it, albeit not always without mental consequence. @Rarity: Did he say everyone should do that?

    • 0

      Giovanni Oliver

      6 months ago

      @valentin: Hitler was a very different scenario. Overpopulation wasn't nearly as big of a problem as it is now, and instead of just killing a relatively small, random number of people, he focused on one main group and killed a relatively significant number of them. And it's "too".

    • 0

      Tokoyami

      5 months ago

      Well personally I don't really know 100 people let alone 10,000. Sooo I think I would risk that near impossible chance that someone I know die from my actions than kill my self. Another thing is I don't think Hitler stopped at 10,000...

    • 0

      Spazyman

      4 months ago

      i have a heart but i agree

    • 0

      moveschris

      3 months ago

      you would kill 10 million people increasing the chances of you or someone you love dying as well. If you live people would obviously hate you making you the most evil person alive.

    • 1

      Ajay

      3 months ago

      Guys the world isn't overpopulated. Everyone in the world could live in texas with the same population density of NYC.

    • 0

      Zaltys

      1 month ago

      Using his burgeoning intelligence, this most successful of all mammals has exploited the environment to produce food for an ever increasing population. Instead of controlling the environment for the benefit of the population, perhaps it is time we control the population to allow the survival of the environment.

    • 1

      hi

      4 weeks ago

      You, my friend, are a selfish, murdering, hater who the world would be better off without. You and all the other reds deserve to die!

    • 0

      hi

      4 weeks ago

      You, my friend, are a selfish, murdering, hater who the world would be better off without. You and all the other reds deserve to die!

    • 0

      hi

      4 weeks ago

      You, my friend, are a selfish, murdering, hater who the world would be better off without. You and all the other reds deserve to die!

    • 0

      Max

      2 weeks ago

      Now we're thinking

  • 31

    Cosmic Hawke

    1 year ago

    Oops my finger slipped

  • 18

    GareBear

    1 year ago

    I like me. I've never met 10,000 people that I like.

  • 12

    Iamright

    9 months ago

    what the fuck is wrong with you people?

    • 0

      nigg

      2 months ago

      what the fuck is wrong with you? who kills themselves

    • 0

      gg470

      3 weeks ago

      Pressing buttons are better than suicide.

  • 11

    that one girl

    1 year ago

    I'd rather end my own life than continue living in such a rotten world. And if i killed ten thousand people that wouldn't make me any better than the people i just killed......

    • 0

      nigg

      2 months ago

      but ur alive retard and they arnt

  • 8

    bendavis630

    9 months ago

    People on red suck

    • 6

      Demon1981

      8 months ago

      People on blue are suicidal.

    • 0

      RyouIshtar

      4 months ago

      Demon: So? It's only religious beliefs that is keeping me here...that and the fear of pain....

  • 8

    Calactus

    9 months ago

    I'd rather end my own life than commit a genocide of such large proportions. 10,000 people... 10,000 men, women, children... innocent, non-innocent. I'd never be able to take their lives away from them because I decide to be selfish.

  • 6

    Reddit

    9 months ago

    Only the really bad people

  • 5

    Aaron Dain

    9 months ago

    Bad Luck Brian: Pushes second button One of the people chosen

  • 5

    Leon8455

    1 year ago

    The population is growing and more stupid people are accumulating so I'd press tah button :D I hate people anyways.

  • 4

    Rap0nmilk

    8 months ago

    i would push the button like 20 times

  • 4

    LuciDaniels

    9 months ago

    A lot of people are commenting that the world is overpopulated anyway... but take a moment to consider this. You are valuing your own life over 10,000 other individuals. Irregardless of the fact that among those killed could be brilliant scientists, world leaders, your family or friends (however unlikely), it is still mass murder. Do you honestly consider yourself to be so important to the world as to be worth 10,000 other lives?

    • 0

      Jazmeow

      6 months ago

      I don't value myself over them.. I just really hate people.

    • 1

      Rafael Tavares

      5 months ago

      Jasmeow - And you want make people hate you. You're sad

  • 4

    Maggie

    9 months ago

    So you'd rather kill 10,000 people then your self? And you can't make yourself feel better by saying "they Might be bad" no. What if your whole family is part of that? And innocent children? I'd rather save 10000 people and take the chance to save innocent people then save myself and say it was fir good reasons. -.-

  • 4

    Anonymous

    9 months ago

    I'm an asshole, what can I say.

  • 4

    jedi obi

    1 year ago

    You could have like 10000 people who hate america and are about to go to war with us

    • 5

      abarnybox

      1 year ago

      says random...silly. It could be 10 000 americans o_O

    • 22

      agindoof

      1 year ago

      you mean who america is about to go to war with.

    • 12

      Iamright

      9 months ago

      oh my god i hope you are kidding! the chance of that does not exist. there is just SO much wrong with that sentence. People like you are the reason the rest of the world hates amreica. I would choose kill myself if the other one was to only kill 2 random people.

    • 4

      Ian

      8 months ago

      This is why the rest of the world hates us.

    • 4

      Toby Marquis

      8 months ago

      It could be someone you love, a celebrity, someone who changed the world, a monarch, a president. Anyone.

    • 0

      tomlol

      7 months ago

      agindoof, you mean everyone, right?

  • 3

    Smattergawl

    8 months ago

    I'd slam the button til I die because I hate everybody

  • 3

    Jordan Clover

    9 months ago

    I'm not a very morally sensitive man...

  • 3

    Petar Petkov

    9 months ago

    Can i press it more than once ?

  • 2

    Zoe

    5 months ago

    Wow people here are sick.

  • 2

    Joshua Nakhoul

    6 months ago

    People are not taking into account that it says everyone would know it was you... So if their family member died, all 10,000 families would be hunting you -.-

  • 1

    Erika

    2 months ago

    Why not both?

  • 2

    Froggers

    8 months ago

    How many times can I push the button? We need some population control.

    • 2

      Rafael Tavares

      5 months ago

      Then kill yourself and also your entire family and friends (if you have one, of course), and you'll be helping a lot!

  • 2

    Andrew Roach

    8 months ago

    I am worth more than 10,000 people! P.S. - I would hit the button twice!

  • 2

    Tony

    8 months ago

    i would tap that button with the force of a thousand suns then turn on the news :D

  • 2

    Noy

    8 months ago

    "The Box"

  • 2

    n00b_PWNr320

    9 months ago

    The differences I make in the world are far less than the differences to be made by 10,000 others.

  • 2

    Jeremy

    9 months ago

    Sorry, motherfuckers.

  • 2

    Bl00dnFl4mes

    9 months ago

    moralfags everywhere

  • 2

    Anthony Johnson

    9 months ago

    Who would kill 10,000 for themselves.

  • 1

    Jason Gabriel

    2 months ago

    The other choice is the epitome of selfishness

  • 2

    UpMyWhatNow

    9 months ago

    i can't just kill 10,000 random people.

  • 2

    reidhasguitar

    9 months ago

    I would kill myself even if I didn't have to press the button otherwise.

  • 2

    some jewish dude

    1 year ago

    cant i kill people that deserve it? then ill be a hero and shit.... DUHHH

  • 1

    itachi727

    3 months ago

    Wow, people are selfish. I wouldn't even be able to live with myself if i was responsible for the death of 10,000 people.

  • 1

    Christina Faith

    3 months ago

    You all are a bunch of sociopaths.

  • 1

    randomwhiteguy

    3 months ago

    I wouldn't be able to live with the fact I killed 10,000 random possibly innocent people

  • 0

    Lana Nienke Zwiers

    1 week ago

    You guys make me want to puke.. Y'all find your own lives more important than the lives of 10000 people? And it's not only those 10000 lives you're ruining.. You're also ruining the lives of their families. Can't believe you all are that cruel..

  • 1

    Cristina Vespucci

    4 months ago

    Ì'm suicidal anyways so why kill innocent people ?

  • 0

    Cupcake

    2 weeks ago

    Well if you kill random people, you might kill yourself

  • 0

    Eden Lobb

    2 weeks ago

    What if after you pushed the button, you found out that your beloved spouse got killed because you were selfish?

  • 0

    Hime kyubi

    3 weeks ago

    I just can't do it. I would probably end up killing myself out of guilt if I killed 10,000 people

  • 1

    commanderpig

    8 months ago

    Its going to be really unfortunate if im one of the 10k

  • 1

    Super_Spliff

    9 months ago

    If I press it twice could I get an extra life?

  • 1

    Keegan M. Lowry

    9 months ago

    shit, double clicked the red button..

  • 1

    wrathseed

    9 months ago

    Fuck humanity

  • 1

    Justin

    9 months ago

    As long as that random person isn't you, theme parks would be great.

  • 0

    halo66333

    4 weeks ago

    With guilt i would take my life through bravery i will save lives

  • 1

    iamjonahXD

    11 months ago

    10,000 people isn't that many...

  • 0

    Midna

    1 month ago

    There could be an off chance that you are one of the 10,000 people. Little chance, but possible. Just putting that out there.

  • 0

    Rockndudette

    1 month ago

    wow 56% of us are bitches

Load More

Tip: Sign up to see adult-rated questions.

Recently Answered

  • You haven't answered any questions yet.

You Rather Mobile

You Rather is available for free on iOS and Android. You're welcome.

For iOS For Android