Add Question

Question Title

Would you rather...

Blue Option
Red Option
 

 

Back to top

Would you rather...

Live in the Star Wars universe

Live in the Star Trek universe

Would you rather...

0%
350,936 agree
Live in the Star Wars universe
0%
73,412 disagree
Live in the Star Trek universe

A Tale of Two Stars

added by Zach Dunn
Loading Comments…

Either way, you're going to space!

Unmoderated: This question has not been reviewed by You Rather moderators. Content may be misformatted, offensive or inappropriate in nature.

142 comments

  • 44

    Jrrd

    3 years ago

    Think about a normal life in each. You can work your way into Star Fleet, but if you aren't born with enough midichlorians, you're not going to be a Jedi.

    • 23

      Sage

      10 months ago

      Blood transplants.

    • 26

      Koen van Herk

      9 months ago

      but I can still join the Mandalorians and become an mercenary/bounty hunter. woohooo

    • 9

      SilasDG

      9 months ago

      Agreed. Working your way up vs being told no by a fascist green alien? I'll take hard work.

    • 19

      yourmom78839

      8 months ago

      SilasDG Fuck you Yoda is way cooler than any Star Trek character.

    • 12

      BKBROWN

      8 months ago

      And in the ST universe you can use replicators and holodecks to give you literally anything

    • 8

      Bobbie Buchanan

      8 months ago

      Everyone in Star Fleet is a genius. If you aren't a genius you'll end up as a Red Shirt or something.

    • 7

      codbl4l

      7 months ago

      Who cares about being a jedi?? There's other lives to live, such as working your way up rebel statuses

    • 6

      Roydon

      7 months ago

      Fuck the Jedi, Sith FTW!

    • 2

      Razael

      7 months ago

      If you don't have an IQ of 240, good luck working your way up that ladder Spock.

    • 1

      Toni Lucas Gajic

      5 months ago

      i am a sith i no care or mercenary!

    • 1

      maxy89c

      4 months ago

      Red Shirt, that is all.

    • 0

      Giorgio Gabriel Guzmán

      4 months ago

      If i was told no by that green alien, then i would turn to te dark side. iwould learn the ways of the Sith no matter what it taes, soon to take my revenge on those who doubted and turned me away. And if they gave me the chance (just so i wouldn't kill them) THEN i would become a Jedi.

    • 1

      EvanLIX

      2 months ago

      Become a smuggler, pirate, bounty hunter, trader, merchant, or farmer.

    • 1

      BizzarreCoyote

      2 months ago

      Don't need to be a Jedi to be an X-Wing pilot

    • 0

      Andrew

      1 month ago

      The Star Wars universe has an army

    • 1

      Zaltys

      1 month ago

      Holodecks, replicators, transporters, advanced healthcare... and you wouldn't have to sign up for the Starfleet, since all those are available for every Federation citizen. What exactly does Star Wars have to offer, besides a short life expectancy?

    • 0

      Jasmine Cyrus

      1 week ago

      SPOCK!

    • 0

      FinMagotti

      1 week ago

      Imma high end bounty hunter, better than bobafett himself

  • 23

    GareBear

    2 years ago

    Who says I give a crap about being a Jedi? True, it'd be a plus, but I'd be a bounty hunter at the very least.

  • 21

    wonderbung

    1 year ago

    I'm a huge fan of both. However, the Trek universe boasts food replicators and mass transmitters. Plus, they don't use money in the Federation. Star Wars is basically the American war of Independence in space followed by never-ending territorial squabbling. Though it would be cool to be a bounty hunter for a while.

  • 15

    Jumanji9700

    2 years ago

    Both would be awesome... but unless you can use The Force, Star Wars universe would loose it's appeal quickly. I'll take beeming up.

  • 11

    Lem

    1 year ago

    Though, I would much prefer the Doctor Who universe.

    • 14

      Chris Danger Gillett

      10 months ago

      You're already living in the DW universe, you're just not the doctor. If you're not the doctor or his companion, the DW universe sucks.

  • 8

    Azer Faraclas

    3 years ago

    Star Trek doesn't have Jawas.

    • 6

      joln

      10 months ago

      But it has Ferengi.

    • 6

      Chris Danger Gillett

      10 months ago

      You must not know much about Star Wars. How many Jawas are there? That's right. It's only a few years before they go extinct.

  • 5

    SentientPuddle

    4 months ago

    Are you people crazy? Regardless of where you fall in the whole "Which is better, Star Wars or Star Trek?" debate, Star Wars is a universe in constant, well, war and spends a great deal of time being oppressed by a fascist dictatorship. In the Star Trek universe, on the other hand, the Earth is a civilized utopia filled with replicators and holodecks. It's kind of a no brainer.

  • 5

    Rowan93

    8 months ago

    What? 82% of people want to be in Star Wars? For most people, that universe is freaking medieval! What the hell?

  • 5

    DJ Mouthwash

    10 months ago

    Tough one. I suppose the Star Trek universe has a better mean standerd of living.

  • 4

    Nick B.

    10 months ago

    There's no Force in the Star Trek universe.

    • 5

      Chris Danger Gillett

      10 months ago

      How likely is it that you will be born a jedi? Almost 0.

    • 2

      Nick B.

      10 months ago

      If you aren't, at least you'll be surrounded by them.

    • 1

      ಠ_ಠ

      9 months ago

      Not necessarily, you could be born into slavery or crime

    • 1

      Jordan

      8 months ago

      Have you never heard of Order 66?

  • 4

    SirAwesomecake

    1 year ago

    There's very little chance of being any kind of Jedi in the Star Wars universe, and that's really all I'd want to be in it. You can be pretty much anywhere in the Star Trek universe and strive to be on a ship of some kind.

    • 0

      Rakin Hamid

      4 months ago

      Being a Jedi - You can use the force, but you only have a damn melee weapon and you're entire life is restricted. Being a Bounty Hunter - Badass epicness.

  • 4

    SnazziestPants

    2 years ago

    The Star Wars universe is more lax and casual, but I do risk being born into slavery. Suffice it to say that being born into the Star Wars universes is like playing the lottery.

    • 10

      Chris Danger Gillett

      10 months ago

      Yea, it's super casual. There is the ocassional bounty hunter, you could be born into slavery, there is a fucking EMPIRE about to kill you (assuming the time periods for SW is 4th movie and ST is TNG). With ST you can replicate food, take showers instantly, and explore the galaxy without the fear of death. If you want a more exciting job, join Starfleet.

    • 4

      Rahma Anderson

      9 months ago

      Chris, you can also be born a normal citizen in one of the awesome city-planets. It doesn't say that you will be one of the characters from the movies.

    • 1

      Razael

      7 months ago

      @chris danger, explore the galaxy without fear of death.....try again. Besides SW is way more cool.

  • 3

    Andy ಠ_ಠ

    9 months ago

    I WANT CHEWY!!! and star wars has some cool and funny characters

  • 3

    Ian

    9 months ago

    Star Wars fans; you're a stormtrooper. Star Trek fans; you're a red shirt. either way, you have terrible aim and die instantly.

  • 3

    Emily

    9 months ago

    Utopian society, replicators, Tribbles.

  • 3

    Captainspock

    10 months ago

    Star Trek is more scientifically accurate...

  • 1

    Lolly

    1 month ago

    I'd rather live in a doctor who universe not some dumb star wars or star treck one

  • 1

    DragonXneoN

    1 month ago

    Star Trek all the way.

  • 2

    keatmar

    8 months ago

    Forget logic. I want a lightsaber!! (^O^)/

  • 2

    Jonathan Trabing

    9 months ago

    Suck it, Trekies.

  • 2

    Prufucius

    9 months ago

    Who cares about being a jedi ? Mercenaries ftw

  • 2

    Josef Correia Herber

    9 months ago

    Star trek universe... Only I would prefer the Stargate Universerse... And to be in an SG team :3

  • 1

    xboxplayer68

    2 months ago

    I absolutely love Star Trek :O

  • 2

    maryellen2011

    1 year ago

    wars vs trekkies? answer=easy. it's the jedi, baby.

    • 6

      Chris Danger Gillett

      10 months ago

      What if you aren't born a jedi? You can't just have a blood transfusion to get mediclorians. You might also be born into slavery.

  • 1

    swexbe

    4 months ago

    I WANNA BE A Q!!

  • 0

    bloodshed109

    2 weeks ago

    you could become half Borg like seven of nine

  • 1

    awesomenessninja

    6 months ago

    Star Trek can suck it

  • 1

    John Himura

    7 months ago

    wtf is a star trek?

  • 0

    Leea

    3 weeks ago

    Do you want to copulate with me?

  • 1

    Jacinda

    7 months ago

    Star wars no question!! Light sabers, the force and adventure at every turn!

  • 0

    wrex111

    3 weeks ago

    pshh Chewbacca, light saber, force.

  • 1

    little man

    8 months ago

    They should make a star trek universe versus star wars universe movie it would be awesome seeing Darth Vader and Yoda working together!

  • 1

    Gian Marco Yepez Rob

    8 months ago

    TWO WORDS: SITH PWNS

  • 1

    Peter

    8 months ago

    I'm sorry, but as much as I love the force, the Star Trek universe is just more pleasant to live in.

  • 0

    Aaron Weiss

    3 weeks ago

    Star Trek is a mostly-ideal legitimately communistic society. Sounds great to me.

  • 1

    Gauldur Blacksoul

    8 months ago

    I would sneak aboard the Death Star and piss on all the controls.

  • 1

    Batman

    9 months ago

    Hmmm a lightsaber to my utility belt...

  • 0

    Alectricity279

    4 weeks ago

    Wars over Trek anyday.

  • 1

    Kelsey Lynn Underwoo

    10 months ago

    star wars.

  • 1

    iamjonahXD

    11 months ago

    You can actually live a life in Star Trek. Star Wars, unless you're a Jedi (which there aren't many of) it wouldn't be much fun.

  • 0

    Microtor

    1 month ago

    Beam me up scotty.

  • 0

    Katie Crosley

    1 month ago

    Lightsabers!

  • 1

    TehSpaceSnake

    1 year ago

    SPAAAAAAACE :3 (space core)

  • 0

    Edd Angelou Dampios

    1 month ago

    I'd like to have me some lightsabers!

  • 1

    zacharydm

    1 year ago

    Only because the likeliness of becoming a Jedi is so small >.>

  • 1

    AbsentFriendHex

    1 year ago

    I already know a bunch of Star Wars trivia, so why not?

  • 0

    Tabatha Barnhart

    1 month ago

    This is a pretty hard choice.

  • 0

    Fatima Ghani

    1 month ago

    That's so unfair!

  • 0

    space rules

    1 month ago

    you dont have to make money in star trek

  • 0

    Kaley Perceful

    2 months ago

    Star Trek universe should always be the answer. You can create any other universe you want on the holodeck, and bam. Now you get both. Why is this even a question.

Load More

Tip: Use the arrow keys to navigate between questions.

Recently Answered

You Rather Mobile

You Rather is available for free on iOS and Android. You're welcome.

For iOS For Android