A toy company is trying to shut us down over the phrase "Would you rather". Here's what we're doing about it »

Add Question

Question Title

Would you rather...

Blue Option
Red Option
 

 

Back to top

Would you rather...

have been to Hogwarts

trained under Obi-Wan Kenobi

Would you rather...

0%
278,681 agree
Have been to Hogwarts
0%
291,882 disagree
Trained under Obi-Wan Kenobi

Skillz

added by Karl
Loading Comments…
Unmoderated: This question has not been reviewed by You Rather moderators. Content may be misformatted, offensive or inappropriate in nature.

254 comments

  • 62

    Rythmbot

    2 years ago

    I'm sorry, but Harry potter universe is so much cooler

    • 51

      overtherainbow

      1 year ago

      Opinions, bro. I'd rather have the force and mind control and all that cool stuff.

    • 36

      RAGC_91

      1 year ago

      damn it i hit agree on accident, meant to hit reply so i could tell you you are a terrible person

    • 15

      Scourge

      1 year ago

      wands, teenage wizards, shitty spells and an ugly, annoying bad guy over The Empire, The Force, Lightsabers and Jedi? you got a fucked up mind bro...

    • 4

      Riley Cantarero

      1 year ago

      your just visiting hogwarts, your becoming a jedi in red

    • 6

      deadmau5

      1 year ago

      Harry Potter Blows Lol.

    • 3

      Stephen Grechis

      1 year ago

      But *space*, dude! And if you're good with the Force you won't even need spells or hexes or anything, you just move shit with your mind.

    • 3

      Franklin Chen

      1 year ago

      ........ Seriously? You'd rather live in magical england than another galaxy full of adventure and action? Fucking dumbass

    • 1

      Fainting Goat

      1 year ago

      @Scourge The bad guy in Star Wars (assuming we're talking about Darth Sidius) is also ugly. But I do agree that the Star Wars universe is better

    • 2

      Gaby

      8 months ago

      Jedis and sith don't need to say stupid things in latin to use their powers

    • 1

      zoop

      8 months ago

      i'm affaird that you're a fucking liar

    • 1

      [deleted]

      8 months ago

      So... you have the option of exploring the galaxy with cool companions and powers, or you go to a school where you learn how to levitate feathers and then go to a normal job and live your life normally till the end. i choose the endless adventure.

    • 1

      billy

      5 months ago

      We don't need the force we have magic that can go to more extents

    • 1

      AlexAnder Katamadze

      5 months ago

      i like Harry Potter universe more and i'd avada kedavra your ass, but it says "have been", so it could be for minutes

    • 1

      Emineminem

      4 months ago

      Hell yeah, Star Wars is awesome, but... HARRY POTTER, BITCHES!

    • 2

      Holy Cow

      3 months ago

      m.youtube.com/watch?v=lRL...RLuPHvF6Fo no screw Harry potter

    • 0

      Kim Kardashian

      3 months ago

      Hi I'm beautiful.

  • 33

    Tiki_Guy

    2 years ago

    Wands beat light sabers. Why go "vroom vroom" when I can go "avada kadabra" and poof, you're dead

    • 85

      xereeto

      2 years ago

      Because if you go "Avada Kadabra" you'll end up in Askaban.

    • 9

      .......SUPRISE......

      1 year ago

      what he said

    • 12

      Kendall Walls

      1 year ago

      Your head will be off before you finish the words... light sabers ftw

    • 47

      AndrogynousPickle

      1 year ago

      Actually, if you go "Avada Kadabra," nothing will happen because that isn't a spell. Avada KeDAVRA," however, WILL get you a one-way ticket to Azkaban. But, still, being a wizard is kick-ass.

    • 23

      ossmosse

      1 year ago

      It said you have been to hogwarts not that you're a wizard or even trained in the wizarding arts, where as you're trained under obi

    • 12

      Jerry Jerryson

      1 year ago

      It's 'leviooooooosa,' not 'leviosaar.' ;)

    • 15

      Fuzzly

      1 year ago

      I'd use the force to rip the wand out your hand, then what?

    • 6

      theTexan

      1 year ago

      @ossmose it never said you were a Jedi maybe you're a trained slave like many on tatooine

    • 4

      Lord English

      1 year ago

      Lightsaber would deflect your bolts. And force choke would prevent uttering spells.

    • 4

      Carlien Muylaert

      1 year ago

      You wouldn't be in hogwarts if you're not a wizard?

    • 5

      Elizabeth

      1 year ago

      because light sabers don't say 'vroom vroom'. I know the smart cars are small, but they aren't light sabers.

    • 0

      Kyle Weaver

      1 year ago

      I think your confused

    • 0

      Lysandro Reina

      1 year ago

      you ppl seem the be forgeting that your jedi reactions will easily make you avoid such a spell

    • 2

      Jane Ogoke

      1 year ago

      Have been to hogwarts= walking around in a bigass school filled with people who can do stuff you can't (exception:Filch). Trained under Obi-Wan=pure awesome.

    • 3

      bekk

      1 year ago

      You chose Hogwarts and you can't even say a simple killing curse? Muggle.

    • 1

      Sean McClellan

      1 year ago

      @theTexan you obviously have never seen one star wars movie, Obi Wan Kenobi wouldnt enslave someone you imbecile.

    • 1

      Franklin Chen

      1 year ago

      @xereeto Damn, nice

    • 0

      MATAEJO

      1 year ago

      Obi wan all the way

    • 0

      Sande Da

      10 months ago

      I'll block it with my light saber

    • 0

      Zachary Card

      8 months ago

      Actually this one youtube channel called ScrewAttack made Luke and Harry fight and analyzed there powers and guess who won, Skywalker.

    • 0

      Zachary Card

      8 months ago

      @theTexan, why would Obi-Wan be training somebody that's not a jedi?

    • 0

      zoop

      8 months ago

      did you foget than you can strangle and electrodute too? even smash them with surrounding stuf and throw them at walls without even touching them

    • 0

      ostrich160

      8 months ago

      Nope. Jedi's are better trained and have better powers

    • 0

      Hayden Jeffrey

      8 months ago

      *avada kadavra*

    • 0

      benndogggg

      8 months ago

      Ur sooooo stupid u have something wrong with ur small Brain

    • 1

      questionsfearmyanswers

      4 months ago

      You go "Avada kedavra" I go *deflect with lightsaber*

    • 0

      dr bigmeat

      3 months ago

      That's not how it works in Harry protect ur statement is incompatable with Han data please reset your bullshit!

    • 0

      HarryPotterFan

      3 weeks ago

      Avada kedavra

    • 0

      Alagane

      2 weeks ago

      Green flashy lasers can be deflected by lightsabers. Plus, the force, like end of story.

  • 9

    -TheDoctor

    1 year ago

    bitch please. I can just use the force and snatch that wand out of your hand. then BOOM. lightsaber to the face.

    • 0

      askMe

      4 months ago

      what if the force is not strong in me. so i prefer be a bad wizard as a bad pada-wan

  • 9

    Horshwa

    2 years ago

    This is a tie for me

  • 7

    Corbin Ballard

    2 years ago

    Endless power or a dumb light saber? Is that even a question????

    • 11

      overtherainbow

      1 year ago

      You're forgetting the force. That includes stuff like mind control.

    • 4

      Martin

      1 year ago

      Endless power doesn't exist within the Harry Potter universe, the magic there is limited.

    • 1

      Asplav

      1 year ago

      where does it say that you learn anything at hogwarts?

    • 0

      Sarius

      1 year ago

      Asplav, because Muggles can't even see Hogwarts let alone be there. So you'd have to have magical abilities (unless you're a squib, but there's no reason to go to Hogwarts as a squib). And you can't exactly leave Hogwarts without having learnt a thing.

  • 6

    Aleksander Mortensen

    1 year ago

    Just because you have been to Hogwarts doesn't mean that you know magic, or that you have a wand. it just meant you went to visit Hogwarts. Trained under Obi-Wan probably means that he's either trained you in the force, or with light-sabers, or both.

    • 2

      MightyLemur

      1 year ago

      Yeah, perhaps you're really bad at magic. All you can do then is make potions.. If the force isn't strong with you, you can still become a badass using a lightsaber.

    • 0

      Alexis Boopie Maceira

      10 months ago

      I think they meant 'attended" Hogwarts.

  • 6

    Viperxiii

    2 years ago

    if the harry potter universe had really cool magic it would be better, but they just never fully make use of it i feel.

  • 5

    pavlotskiy

    1 year ago

    Damn it everyone forgets magneto :(

  • 4

    Emmett Lowe

    1 year ago

    51/49 ..... i dont want to live on this planet anymore ._.

    • 0

      Gaby

      8 months ago

      Go on Coruscant, it's way better

  • 4

    SPeNCeYBoii

    2 years ago

    Well, i have a freaking light-saber! and also i have the force which means i can control minds, objects and substances. also i can give do super jumps and flips!

  • 3

    Milad Sabah

    1 year ago

    da fuc* who wouldn't go to Hogwarts!?

  • 3

    caucasianDANGERmachine

    1 year ago

    Crazy, horrible shit was always going down at that school...plus, they were in school, which sucks. And light sabers are the bees tits, get with it magic nerds.

  • 0

    Edward Fellow

    1 day ago

    Jedis can make stuff fly and control minds, wizards can do both and a lot more soo yeah.

  • 0

    omega_wolf

    3 days ago

    Look what a bad job obi wan did the anakin, and training luke didnt go so well cause it ended up getting himself sort of killed by darth vader in the 4th one

  • 2

    Maggie

    1 year ago

    Wizards can do everything Jedis can and more! Plus Jedis can't have relationships or they'll turn evil. Sooooo you gotta choose Hogwarts if you have any sense!

  • 2

    Mauro Fonseca

    1 year ago

    I didnt need to read the other option

  • 2

    Jordan Rogers

    1 year ago

    I'm assuming he meant you'd be a wizard and able to use the force?

  • 2

    RealityWarping

    1 year ago

    Lightsabers are awesome no doubt about it. Cut through your body before you have time to say 'Avada Kedavra'. Being given one and trained with it with Obi-Wan Kenobi would be epic.

  • 2

    Aidan Kearns

    1 year ago

    would you really want to expeloramious a light saber? that could be disasterous.

  • 2

    Sarah Peek

    1 year ago

    I will not give up on getting my letter!

  • 2

    JuryIsOut

    1 year ago

    Emma Watson.

  • 2

    Dustin Adams

    1 year ago

    Only if it was Qui-Gon Jinn, then you are basically getting trained by Ra's Al Ghul. That would be boss.

    • 4

      RealityWarping

      1 year ago

      I wouldn't mind getting the shit beaten out of me while training with either of them for some reason.

  • 2

    John

    1 year ago

    See if I became a Jedi, I could have a padowan if I wanted and could create basically modern day star wars with jedis everywhere.....and sith

  • 0

    darkaquarian

    6 days ago

    Jedi mind trix own

  • 0

    Philosopher

    1 week ago

    Either sounds awesome

  • 0

    nigeritis

    1 week ago

    Trained under kenobi doesnt necesarilly mean you have the force right? He could just make you a ninja. But you dont get to hogwarts unless youre a wizard

  • 0

    kewlpat

    2 weeks ago

    Light saber deflects your spells like it deflects lasers

  • 0

    HarryPotterFan

    3 weeks ago

    HARRY POTTER ALL THE WAY!!!!!!!

  • 1

    Jared Vance

    8 months ago

    Only reason I am choosing Hogwarts: I can go home for the weekend if I choose without the hassle of airlines

  • 0

    Haleywainwrite

    3 weeks ago

    Hardest question of my life

  • 0

    backwhat

    3 weeks ago

    $ffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff$ffvndyfgejrdggcyvvhgbb

  • 0

    ahobowithastick

    4 weeks ago

    Maybe using the force and shit would be fun, but after reading the series, casting spells and living in the world of magic seems so much more appealing.

  • 1

    Faye Daigler

    11 months ago

    I mean, I guess I've got a 50/50 chance of succumbing to the Dark Side and regretting my entire life, but I'd have a lightsaber.

  • 1

    Johnathan

    1 year ago

    You have to be close for a saber to work. Not so much with a wand.

  • 1

    Nynrahman

    1 year ago

    I just prefer Sci-Fi to Fantasy

  • 1

    Jeshua Amalesh

    1 year ago

    It doesn't say if u actually learn something at Hogwarts :)

  • 1

    Tommapar

    1 year ago

    LIGHTSABERS BITCH

  • 1

    Elizabeth

    1 year ago

    Harry Potter is pretty freaking adorable.

  • 0

    Sonny

    1 month ago

    Obi one

  • 1

    Kelcey Howeth

    1 year ago

    Wow. Somepeople must not have read Harry Potter.

    • 2

      bobaskus

      1 year ago

      It says ''have been to hogwarts'' it dosent say ''attend hogwarts''

  • 1

    EdwardNigma

    1 year ago

    You don't get to train at hogwarts. And thus, I'd rather be a master with a light saber and the force.

  • 1

    Kai Bakken

    1 year ago

    Fucking choking bitches

  • 1

    Eugene Wunclerthefou

    1 year ago

    Some faith in humanity has been restored?

  • 1

    Colbywan

    1 year ago

    seriously, if you want to go to hogwarts over having command of the force...you have issues

  • 1

    Jordan Clover

    1 year ago

    Jedi>Pussy wizards, any day, all day

  • 1

    asdasdasdas

    1 year ago

    What happens if you're a squib?

  • 1

    Tristan Gonzalez

    1 year ago

    if you go to hogwarts it could just be a tour

  • 1

    Jacob

    1 year ago

    I will use the force to take your wand away. What do you do now?

  • 1

    Martin

    1 year ago

    Have been to Hogwarts, says nothing about actually being able to perform magic, whereas to be trained by Obi-Wan is granted to give you some degree of control over the force.

  • 1

    JesterOfDestiny

    1 year ago

    I won't need a wand.

Load More

Tip: Use the arrow keys to navigate between questions.

Recently Answered

You Rather Mobile

You Rather is available for free on iOS and Android. You're welcome.

For iOS For Android