Add Question

Question Title

Would you rather...

Blue Option
Red Option
 

 

Back to top

Would you rather...

48% have been to Hogwarts

52% trained under Obi-Wan Kenobi

Would you rather...

48%
189,726 agree
Have been to Hogwarts
52%
201,919 disagree
Trained under Obi-Wan Kenobi

Skillz

added by Karl
Loading Comments…
Unmoderated: This question has not been reviewed by You Rather moderators. Content may be misformatted, offensive or inappropriate in nature.

162 comments

  • 39

    Rythmbot

    1 year ago

    I'm sorry, but Harry potter universe is so much cooler

    • 29

      overtherainbow

      1 year ago

      Opinions, bro. I'd rather have the force and mind control and all that cool stuff.

    • 26

      RAGC_91

      9 months ago

      damn it i hit agree on accident, meant to hit reply so i could tell you you are a terrible person

    • 8

      Scourge

      6 months ago

      wands, teenage wizards, shitty spells and an ugly, annoying bad guy over The Empire, The Force, Lightsabers and Jedi? you got a fucked up mind bro...

    • 1

      Riley Cantarero

      5 months ago

      your just visiting hogwarts, your becoming a jedi in red

    • 2

      deadmau5

      5 months ago

      Harry Potter Blows Lol.

    • 2

      Stephen Grechis

      3 months ago

      But *space*, dude! And if you're good with the Force you won't even need spells or hexes or anything, you just move shit with your mind.

    • 1

      Franklin Chen

      2 months ago

      ........ Seriously? You'd rather live in magical england than another galaxy full of adventure and action? Fucking dumbass

    • 0

      Fainting Goat

      1 month ago

      @Scourge The bad guy in Star Wars (assuming we're talking about Darth Sidius) is also ugly. But I do agree that the Star Wars universe is better

  • 16

    Tiki_Guy

    1 year ago

    Wands beat light sabers. Why go "vroom vroom" when I can go "avada kadabra" and poof, you're dead

    • 68

      xereeto

      1 year ago

      Because if you go "Avada Kadabra" you'll end up in Askaban.

    • 7

      .......SUPRISE......

      10 months ago

      what he said

    • 9

      Kendall Walls

      10 months ago

      Your head will be off before you finish the words... light sabers ftw

    • 32

      AndrogynousPickle

      10 months ago

      Actually, if you go "Avada Kadabra," nothing will happen because that isn't a spell. Avada KeDAVRA," however, WILL get you a one-way ticket to Azkaban. But, still, being a wizard is kick-ass.

    • 15

      ossmosse

      10 months ago

      It said you have been to hogwarts not that you're a wizard or even trained in the wizarding arts, where as you're trained under obi

    • 10

      Jerry Jerryson

      9 months ago

      It's 'leviooooooosa,' not 'leviosaar.' ;)

    • 10

      Fuzzly

      9 months ago

      I'd use the force to rip the wand out your hand, then what?

    • 3

      theTexan

      8 months ago

      @ossmose it never said you were a Jedi maybe you're a trained slave like many on tatooine

    • 0

      Lord English

      8 months ago

      Lightsaber would deflect your bolts. And force choke would prevent uttering spells.

    • 2

      Carlien Muylaert

      7 months ago

      You wouldn't be in hogwarts if you're not a wizard?

    • 2

      Elizabeth

      7 months ago

      because light sabers don't say 'vroom vroom'. I know the smart cars are small, but they aren't light sabers.

    • 0

      Kyle Weaver

      6 months ago

      I think your confused

    • 0

      Lysandro Reina

      5 months ago

      you ppl seem the be forgeting that your jedi reactions will easily make you avoid such a spell

    • 0

      Jane Ogoke

      4 months ago

      Have been to hogwarts= walking around in a bigass school filled with people who can do stuff you can't (exception:Filch). Trained under Obi-Wan=pure awesome.

    • 0

      bekk

      4 months ago

      You chose Hogwarts and you can't even say a simple killing curse? Muggle.

    • 0

      Sean McClellan

      3 months ago

      @theTexan you obviously have never seen one star wars movie, Obi Wan Kenobi wouldnt enslave someone you imbecile.

    • 0

      Franklin Chen

      2 months ago

      @xereeto Damn, nice

    • 0

      MATAEJO

      2 months ago

      Obi wan all the way

  • 8

    -TheDoctor

    10 months ago

    bitch please. I can just use the force and snatch that wand out of your hand. then BOOM. lightsaber to the face.

  • 7

    Corbin Ballard

    1 year ago

    Endless power or a dumb light saber? Is that even a question????

    • 9

      overtherainbow

      1 year ago

      You're forgetting the force. That includes stuff like mind control.

    • 2

      Martin

      9 months ago

      Endless power doesn't exist within the Harry Potter universe, the magic there is limited.

    • 1

      Asplav

      9 months ago

      where does it say that you learn anything at hogwarts?

    • 0

      Sarius

      3 months ago

      Asplav, because Muggles can't even see Hogwarts let alone be there. So you'd have to have magical abilities (unless you're a squib, but there's no reason to go to Hogwarts as a squib). And you can't exactly leave Hogwarts without having learnt a thing.

  • 7

    Horshwa

    1 year ago

    This is a tie for me

  • 6

    Aleksander Mortensen

    1 year ago

    Just because you have been to Hogwarts doesn't mean that you know magic, or that you have a wand. it just meant you went to visit Hogwarts. Trained under Obi-Wan probably means that he's either trained you in the force, or with light-sabers, or both.

    • 2

      MightyLemur

      9 months ago

      Yeah, perhaps you're really bad at magic. All you can do then is make potions.. If the force isn't strong with you, you can still become a badass using a lightsaber.

  • 4

    SPeNCeYBoii

    1 year ago

    Well, i have a freaking light-saber! and also i have the force which means i can control minds, objects and substances. also i can give do super jumps and flips!

  • 4

    Viperxiii

    1 year ago

    if the harry potter universe had really cool magic it would be better, but they just never fully make use of it i feel.

  • 2

    Milad Sabah

    3 months ago

    da fuc* who wouldn't go to Hogwarts!?

  • 2

    Aidan Kearns

    9 months ago

    would you really want to expeloramious a light saber? that could be disasterous.

  • 2

    Dustin Adams

    9 months ago

    Only if it was Qui-Gon Jinn, then you are basically getting trained by Ra's Al Ghul. That would be boss.

    • 2

      RealityWarping

      9 months ago

      I wouldn't mind getting the shit beaten out of me while training with either of them for some reason.

  • 2

    John

    10 months ago

    See if I became a Jedi, I could have a padowan if I wanted and could create basically modern day star wars with jedis everywhere.....and sith

  • 2

    caucasianDANGERmachine

    10 months ago

    Crazy, horrible shit was always going down at that school...plus, they were in school, which sucks. And light sabers are the bees tits, get with it magic nerds.

  • 2

    Emmett Lowe

    10 months ago

    51/49 ..... i dont want to live on this planet anymore ._.

  • 0

    Matt

    2 days ago

    Go obi wan

  • 0

    Matt

    2 days ago

    Go obi wan

  • 1

    Jeshua Amalesh

    4 months ago

    It doesn't say if u actually learn something at Hogwarts :)

  • 0

    Kyle Chainey

    1 week ago

    Hermione. Case closed.

  • 0

    FizCap

    1 week ago

    I'm sorry,but harry potter is gay.

  • 1

    Mauro Fonseca

    6 months ago

    I didnt need to read the other option

  • 1

    Tommapar

    7 months ago

    LIGHTSABERS BITCH

  • 1

    Elizabeth

    7 months ago

    Harry Potter is pretty freaking adorable.

  • 1

    Jordan Rogers

    8 months ago

    I'm assuming he meant you'd be a wizard and able to use the force?

  • 1

    Kelcey Howeth

    8 months ago

    Wow. Somepeople must not have read Harry Potter.

    • 2

      bobaskus

      8 months ago

      It says ''have been to hogwarts'' it dosent say ''attend hogwarts''

  • 0

    Filipp Pöyhönen

    3 weeks ago

    Magic is... well.. Magical! But Psynergy would be way better.

  • 1

    Amon

    8 months ago

    You don't get to train at hogwarts. And thus, I'd rather be a master with a light saber and the force.

  • 1

    Kai Bakken

    9 months ago

    Fucking choking bitches

  • 1

    Eugene Wunclerthefou

    9 months ago

    Some faith in humanity has been restored?

  • 1

    Colbywan

    9 months ago

    seriously, if you want to go to hogwarts over having command of the force...you have issues

  • 1

    RealityWarping

    9 months ago

    Lightsabers are awesome no doubt about it. Cut through your body before you have time to say 'Avada Kedavra'. Being given one and trained with it with Obi-Wan Kenobi would be epic.

  • 1

    Sarah Peek

    9 months ago

    I will not give up on getting my letter!

  • 1

    JuryIsOut

    9 months ago

    Emma Watson.

  • 1

    Jordan Clover

    9 months ago

    Jedi>Pussy wizards, any day, all day

  • 1

    asdasdasdas

    9 months ago

    What happens if you're a squib?

  • 1

    Tristan Gonzalez

    9 months ago

    if you go to hogwarts it could just be a tour

  • 1

    Jacob

    9 months ago

    I will use the force to take your wand away. What do you do now?

  • 1

    Martin

    9 months ago

    Have been to Hogwarts, says nothing about actually being able to perform magic, whereas to be trained by Obi-Wan is granted to give you some degree of control over the force.

  • 1

    JesterOfDestiny

    9 months ago

    I won't need a wand.

  • 1

    hamm0ndeggs

    9 months ago

    This doesn't say anything about being trained at Hogwarts.

  • 0

    Faye Daigler

    4 weeks ago

    I mean, I guess I've got a 50/50 chance of succumbing to the Dark Side and regretting my entire life, but I'd have a lightsaber.

  • 1

    .......SUPRISE......

    10 months ago

    going to hogwarts? i visited there i dont know how to hold a wand pfft ez choice going doesnt mean ur all harry potter all of a sudden

  • 1

    Will

    11 months ago

    the force as far as you know youve never been to hogwarts and im more handsome then john stamos o yea and bam you just shot yourself in the head what up magic queers

  • 0

    Maaz Mahmood

    1 month ago

    Deflect spells? Really? Dumbest thing I've ever heard

  • 0

    space rules

    1 month ago

    anyone trained under obi-wan could beat a wizard(s)

  • 0

    sororitygirl

    2 months ago

    Seeing as in the 7th book most students die horrific deaths.....

  • 0

    Johnathan

    2 months ago

    You have to be close for a saber to work. Not so much with a wand.

  • 0

    Cordt Callum

    2 months ago

    Light saber v.s. Wand? Bith Please!

  • 0

    Griffo Frumblefoot

    2 months ago

    hogwarts is cooler but i like star wars to

  • 0

    Jerica Jane Cary

    2 months ago

    Oh...oh my god. I'm going to be a jedi..

  • 0

    Dewy

    2 months ago

    How is that even debatable? Mastering the force means immortality and power way beyond that of faggy hogwarts...

Load More

Tip: Sign up to see adult-rated questions.

Recently Answered

You Rather Mobile

You Rather is available for free on iOS and Android. You're welcome.

For iOS For Android