A toy company is trying to shut us down over the phrase "Would you rather". Here's what we're doing about it »

Add Question

Question Title

Would you rather...

Blue Option
Red Option
 

 

Back to top

Would you rather...

20% Be killed in a Saw movie

80% Be killed in a Final Destination movie

Would you rather...

20%
128,479 agree
Be killed in a Saw movie
80%
528,822 disagree
Be killed in a Final Destination movie

Horror Film Debut (and End)

added by Patrick
Loading Comments…
Unmoderated: This question has not been reviewed by You Rather moderators. Content may be misformatted, offensive or inappropriate in nature.

180 comments

  • 165

    eah

    4 years ago

    At least in Final Destination it would be quick!

    • 46

      Dave

      1 year ago

      And, with luck, I may not know how I'll die...

    • 10

      webster2086

      1 year ago

      Quick? Have you not seen the movies? Plus you will be some paranoid freak if that was to happen

    • 131

      RikuXander

      1 year ago

      But I want to play a game~

    • 6

      Kendall And Izzy ★

      1 year ago

      OMG Ya

    • 0

      Tommapar

      1 year ago

      My thoughts exactly!

    • 1

      no thankth

      1 year ago

      what about the slow painful deaths in FD? (i choose randomly)

    • 2

      DOYOUEVENLIFT

      1 year ago

      Wow , riku. That comment really made me laugh..

    • 0

      Trelista Blubaugh

      1 year ago

      @DOYOUEVENLIFT Dat username.

    • 2

      Deadnought

      1 year ago

      And it would be really awesome.

    • 8

      Meg

      1 year ago

      But in saw you can (rarely) win

    • 11

      Thingyea

      1 year ago

      @Meg. It says 'be killed' so there is no chance of escape

    • 2

      Jose Ignacio

      10 months ago

      That's not true you can die slowly and painfuly too!

    • 2

      Darksword527

      9 months ago

      who cares you'd be killed by a puppet controlled by an insane guy and plus i can saw my shackles off

    • 0

      Kasterion

      9 months ago

      I forgot that they don't kill in the Saw movies....but then i saw it said Be KILLED in a saw movie

    • 0

      Mephiste

      5 months ago

      QUICK?? Don't you remember the girls that burned alive?!

    • 0

      Liam Haney

      1 month ago

      Not all the time...but most deaths aren't based on torture in FD, so yeah

    • 0

      Brady Bargren

      1 month ago

      All the people who died in saw were pussies anyway.

    • 0

      Cody Dudash

      3 weeks ago

      Fuck that shit! I want it to be quick, not long and painful.

  • 31

    Jumanji9700

    3 years ago

    You die in both... you're tortured in Saw first though..................

    • 5

      rolf69

      1 year ago

      but you can have a chance of survival

    • 12

      Veronica Rouby

      1 year ago

      But the question says you would be killed, so for the sake of the question, you don't.

    • 1

      minefwd

      7 months ago

      My thoughts exactly

  • 19

    VSpartan

    1 year ago

    I died in Final Destination because I was supposed to die in Saw, but didn't. I cheated death in Saw and now it's coming for me.... that's how I'll die.

  • 18

    overtherainbow

    2 years ago

    Saw - Suffer from torture and psychological damage before death. Final Destination - quick death, and usually you're with friends or something. Good way to go out.

  • 18

    Derek

    4 years ago

    The real issue for me is that I just flat out don't want to be in a Saw movie.

  • 17

    iamdrebbits

    3 years ago

    Hate to confront Jigsaw. And dying in Final Destination is pretty quick.

  • 11

    Mitchell Guptill

    1 year ago

    FD is much better.

  • 7

    Tiki_Guy

    2 years ago

    I still don't understand why people pay 10 bucks to watch people die in the most gruesome ways imaginable

  • 7

    Grickel

    2 years ago

    i wouldnt want to be trapped in a room with a albino clown looking at you

  • 7

    dsshorty89

    4 years ago

    If you're dieing from Saw movie that means you didn't play the game right. Let death come get me

  • 5

    Roast Toast

    1 year ago

    I'd rather not get killed, but at least I'm not told to gouge out my eye to get the key to turn off the face shredder attached to me.

    • 2

      wartpig

      1 year ago

      gotta think a bit more. he did a surgery to get the key there and recently. so fresh nerve damage and go in the same way he did. there wouldnt be anymore new pain than what your feeling from what he did. source: ive had my entire rib cage re built. fresh wounds are painlessly re opened

  • 3

    Pranav Arya

    1 year ago

    Let's play a game....and LOSE!

  • 3

    luke

    2 years ago

    Yah but wouldn't u have a chance to escape in saw?

    • 1

      Demon1981

      2 years ago

      It says you have to be killed so yes you have a chance but by the question you are not able to

  • 3

    7r3v0r13

    2 years ago

    Final destination blows!!

    • 2

      Natalie

      1 year ago

      Definitely, that's why I would rather die in it. The deaths aren't half as torturous.

  • 3

    Guy Murcko

    2 years ago

    both suck

  • 3

    MissHorrorshow

    2 years ago

    Seeing as Saw is CLEARLY the superior franchise, it wins, hands down.

    • 9

      allan

      2 years ago

      ud want to be torchered?!?!?! WTF?

    • 13

      MissHorrorshow

      2 years ago

      Well, neither franchise offers nice, comfy ways to die and not everyone is tortured in Saw. The jawripper, shotgun collar, and other gadgets I can't remember because I just woke up, were all fairly instantaneous ways to die. The bigger point though is that avoiding death in the first place is easier in the Saw franchise. In Saw, don't be a junkie, appreciate the life you're given, be a decent human being and you should be ok. A greater point, in Saw you have a chance to possibly survive, slim though it may be (unless Amanda made your trap, then sorry 'bout your luck.). In Final Destination to avoid death you have to...die. You have to totally ignore your inherent, natural drive to prevent the death of yourself and either people you care about, or people who you'd never willingly allow to die (parents, their kids, etc) and allow a gruesome death to befall you all...OR you and the other supposed-to-be victims can live the rest of your lives in sheer terror of the day your number comes up and you get to die an even more gruesome death individually. Yeah, I'm still taking Saw.

    • 8

      VSpartan

      1 year ago

      Except it didn't say you get to live.... you WILL be killed. I'd rather my death potentially be less grotesque and not as a pawn in the games of a mad man.

    • 0

      Pradidye

      2 months ago

      Hands down, on the table, separated from your body...

  • 2

    LiLo:)

    7 months ago

    Hello, I want to play a game!

  • 2

    zobo fo sho

    1 year ago

    So basically, the question is: Get tortured then die or Know you're going to die, then die.

  • 0

    Julio Ferreira

    4 days ago

    I dont think 20,000 people have seen SAW

  • 2

    Weeaboss

    1 year ago

    Final Destination deaths are usually quicker and less horrifying. In fact, some of them are downright hilarious.

    • 2

      no thankth

      1 year ago

      and what about the one where the girls were fired alive in the tanning booths?

  • 2

    God of Knowledge

    1 year ago

    The God of Knowledge has yet to view either franchise, as he sees gruesome, torturous deaths in movies much less entertaining than they are live and in person.

  • 2

    Leah Zugg

    1 year ago

    Wrong one ...

  • 0

    Salina

    1 week ago

    I agree....I'd much rather want the unexpected and quicker death than whatever lies in the Saw scenario

  • 2

    jazzhands

    2 years ago

    Final Destination is about falling off a rollercoaster, right?

    • 1

      Crissy

      2 years ago

      There's 5 Final Destination movies, in order it's a plane exploding, a huge car wreck, Roller coaster, Racecar accident, then a bridge collapse.

    • 2

      Michael Baram

      1 year ago

      there are a LOT of ways to die in FD. it's not just the first death scene

    • 0

      sourprince

      1 month ago

      Atleast I'll have fun before I die

  • 2

    Mummer16

    2 years ago

    be one of the first people to die so that I'm not freaking out and trying to avoid everything in order to stay alive. Instead ill just go on with my life until I die in some accident.

  • 1

    glitchface

    4 months ago

    MOAR FUN!!!!!

  • 1

    spartan1337

    8 months ago

    Nobody said anything about really dying, just about dying IN a movie.

  • 1

    laa_bambinaa

    9 months ago

    I would rather not 'play a game' (._.)/~~

  • 0

    Lyons

    4 weeks ago

    FD deaths are generally less painful and they usually are much faster than Saw deaths (excluding that eye surgery thing).

  • 1

    Suicidalsyd

    10 months ago

    Got to be saw! You can test how much and how far you would go to save your life!

  • 0

    WalkaWalk

    1 month ago

    Saw sucks even before you get killed. The Angel trap is steel bars just stabbed into your chest!

  • 1

    Stewiepwn

    1 year ago

    Yeah, die scared shitless being forced to disfigure yourself.

  • 1

    samsung

    1 year ago

    Saw movie painful. Final destination movie Badass.

  • 1

    nyancat123801

    1 year ago

    At least in saw you get to look like bane

  • 1

    kali

    1 year ago

    saw is just horrrible

  • 1

    Dutchie

    1 year ago

    guys com on, it says in a movie. movies aren't real. you wouldn't be dying you'd just be acting out a death

  • 0

    Casey Burns

    1 month ago

    more creative and damn near instant.

  • 1

    Nosfera2

    1 year ago

    Final Destination because it would be funnier.

  • 1

    pcolyn

    1 year ago

    At least I'd be killed with style...

  • 1

    MultiFlyingPanda

    1 year ago

    saw.... aaahhh you get killed VERY painfully

  • 0

    Allacazar

    1 month ago

    At least I would die a hilarious and quick way :)

  • 0

    SuperFist7

    1 month ago

    At least I'd have a chance to live

  • 0

    UrbanMilkman

    1 month ago

    It would be quicker in fd

  • 0

    maddison

    1 month ago

    In saw u never win

  • 0

    Wareagle17

    2 months ago

    I accidentally pressed saw so one vote is wrong

  • 0

    Jonas Aagaard

    2 months ago

    It says killed "in the ____ MOVIE"! This way we don't die in real life. I'd say it's cooler when someone dies in Saw than in FD.

  • 0

    unknown name

    2 months ago

    Saw is painful and fd is quick and painless so yeah

  • 0

    VisceralPollo

    2 months ago

    It depends on which Saw death or FD death you are talking about!

  • 0

    anissaann99

    2 months ago

    In a saw movie you can either save or kill yourself so I picked saw

  • 0

    theawesomeking

    2 months ago

    Easy

Load More

Tip: Use the arrow keys to navigate between questions.

Recently Answered

You Rather Mobile

You Rather is available for free on iOS and Android. You're welcome.

For iOS For Android