Add Question

Question Title

Would you rather...

Blue Option
Red Option
 

 

Back to top

Would you rather...

Eat a cup of baking soda and then do a shot of vinegar

Eat a pack of Mentos and then chug a Diet Coke

Would you rather...

0%
63,913 agree
Eat a cup of baking soda and then do a shot of vinegar
0%
366,359 disagree
Eat a pack of Mentos and then chug a Diet Coke

Chemical Reaction

added by Brian
Loading Comments…
Unmoderated: This question has not been reviewed by You Rather moderators. Content may be misformatted, offensive or inappropriate in nature.

166 comments

  • 130

    Brendan

    3 years ago

    It has the same result, just tastes better.

    • 16

      ClosRey

      8 months ago

      The baking soda and vinegar don't have as big as of a reaction as mentos

    • 13

      sam

      7 months ago

      waterfall out your mouth ftw

    • 3

      I Dream of Air Time

      7 months ago

      You lose all your teeth the other way and face high chance of choking to death, as it has happened to others before.

    • 1

      T.P.N

      6 months ago

      i hate cola

    • 10

      Generalspaz

      6 months ago

      It's called chewing... Nothing would happen if you chewed the mentos

    • 1

      kwakuduckguy

      6 months ago

      COKE MAN!!!

    • 2

      kwakuduckguy

      6 months ago

      SHIT!! didnt mean that I take it back.

    • 1

      tribute4life

      3 months ago

      Volcano In Your Mouth!

    • 2

      wartpig

      3 months ago

      you people are dumb neither will do anything. research it. it only works in a bottle. you will just burp or fart alot

    • 4

      becca_and_snauss

      3 months ago

      mythbusters proved that it doesnt do anything so it just tastes good

    • 1

      XxxxBlack.Veil.BridesxxxX

      3 months ago

      this seems more fun, ever tried 7up and a bannana...

  • 24

    bones

    2 years ago

    ether way stumic will explode die more tasty way

    • 45

      iluvkfc

      10 months ago

      Upvoted for stumic.

    • 19

      James

      8 months ago

      Sorry man, Mythbusters proved that your stumic will not explode

    • 2

      Kenneth

      7 months ago

      @James Dude, I saw that episode. Though the stomach did not explode, it expanded so much to the point that it would push other organs out of the way! You would have passed out unconscious from the reaction. Now I know nothing about baking soda and vinegar, but I chose that because I knew about the other.

    • 0

      Tim Schneider

      6 months ago

      @James Even though their test turned up nothing, they still had a real story where it happened. So they couldn't discount it completely.

  • 22

    kyliecarefree

    1 year ago

    They don't say how much time you get to have between the eating and drinking, so soda and mentos it is!

  • 17

    Derek

    3 years ago

    Sure, they may be essentially the same thing from a results point of view. However, where one is labeled an "urban legend," the other is labeled as A VOLCANO.

  • 12

    MarkTheGr8

    1 year ago

    Mentos and coke does nothing when eaten and drunk.. Tried it and was disappointed.

  • 12

    babalooskies

    3 years ago

    i've done this before. it's awesome.

  • 7

    Alejandro Arvizu

    1 year ago

    Mythbusters.

  • 5

    Cait

    3 years ago

    the mentos and coke would at least taste better

  • 4

    HeathersProp

    1 year ago

    diet coke and mentos taste a lot better than vinegar and anything!! And the smell of vinegar? ugh. .

  • 3

    Aidan Kearns

    10 months ago

    well, this will be the most awesome puke ever

  • 2

    Brad Hickey

    3 months ago

    Mentos. The effect doesn't happen in the stomach. The acids cancel out the reaction from the mentos.

  • 3

    Big D

    1 year ago

    if you eat mentos, they are chewed up therefore nothing will happen when mixed with coke. havent you guys watched mythbusters??

  • 3

    Nick

    1 year ago

    baking soda is disgusting...

  • 1

    Jake

    1 month ago

    It wont do anything because my gastric juices will alter the mentos. also baking soda is only for brushing teeth (in some cases) and baking stuff.

  • 1

    ColeYote

    2 months ago

    Fecking hate vinegar.

  • 2

    Nat

    9 months ago

    Vinegar tastes better than Diet Coke.

  • 0

    ilostthegame

    16 hours ago

    I'd just regurgitate foam everywhere. That sounds fun.

  • 0

    Thea T.

    17 hours ago

    I have seen people do that. I haven't seen someone do the blue option.

  • 0

    Miss Kneesocks

    2 days ago

    If you didn't use the mint kind of mentos it wouldn't work. I've tested it.

  • 0

    Lauren Pursey

    3 days ago

    Mythbusters tested what would happen, the reaction happens because the mentos make the undisturbed CO2 bubbles release, pouring it down your throat makes it lose the potential, nothing would happen

  • 2

    breasts

    1 year ago

    diet coke is terribad

  • 0

    mrgingersnapsnap

    5 days ago

    Well since it said eat, I'm assuming the mentos/baking soda is no longer in my mouth when I chug the coke/vinegar...so nothing would happen, if you chose the baking soda and vinegar because the reaction is not as large as the other, you would have that terrible taste in your mouth for pretty much no reason at all.

  • 1

    Len Kromkamp

    3 months ago

    I once tried this but I already ate the mentos so the effect was lessened a lot. But I felt my stomach growing, was funny :)

  • 0

    madisonthecutie

    1 week ago

    ni!!! nither ok that im jst ahhhhhh

  • 0

    Dakota Williamson

    2 weeks ago

    Diet Coke pouring like waterfalls.

  • 1

    Alfie Tait

    7 months ago

    dont say about chewing

  • 0

    NineDiamands9

    3 weeks ago

    Ok I said eat mentos but really guys who wants to be blasted with coke?

  • 1

    Cody

    9 months ago

    What's with the diet coke? Why so specific?

  • 0

    daniel

    3 weeks ago

    tastes better and vinegar is bs

  • 1

    Jessie Sofen

    9 months ago

    I so did not mean to click this one. Diet Coke and Mentos would be so much more tasty than baking soda and vinegar. This app needs a confirmation button or something.

  • 1

    kodai

    10 months ago

    ive done that once, nothing happened

  • 0

    D0CT0RWH0

    4 weeks ago

    The Coke and Mentos thing doesn't work after the Coke is poured

  • 1

    Kameron

    10 months ago

    vinegar and baking soda just makes a lot of gas mentos and coke make a explosion

    • 0

      FreezingFire

      3 months ago

      either way nothing happens, so I would rather eat something good than a mouthful of disgusting

  • 1

    PoeticBagel

    11 months ago

    Nothing will happen either way, and the Mentos will actually taste good...

    • 1

      Mossy

      10 months ago

      You clearly never saw the Mentos + Diet Coke fad videos.

    • 0

      Ash Alopex

      9 months ago

      Mossy, the chemical reaction would be nullified by your digestive juices anyway.

  • 1

    medusaman

    1 year ago

    Mentos and coke rocks! I do this regularly.

  • 0

    Moss Grande

    1 month ago

    I tried it and nothing happened.

  • 0

    Marc Pannullo

    1 month ago

    you puke either way...

  • 0

    Marc Pannullo

    1 month ago

    you puke either way...

  • 0

    Alec Henson

    2 months ago

    I watched a dude do this at school. he puked fizzy slowness.

  • 0

    Jason Ku

    2 months ago

    If you wash the mentos with waters to the point where they smooth over, no reaction will occur with the diet coke.

  • 0

    Lengi

    2 months ago

    Eating mentos then chugging coke does absolutely nothing in terms of fizzing up. Eatch mythbusters

  • 0

    RealityWarping

    2 months ago

    This sounds much more interesting...

  • 0

    ThaPengwin

    2 months ago

    It's been proven by scientists - your stomach disables the effects of coke with mentos :P

  • 0

    gloireasatan

    2 months ago

    I actually don't think Diet Coke and Mentos would work if you chew the Mentos. And, even if you did end up Hydro Pumping, it would taste a lot better.

  • 0

    Reut Cherniak

    2 months ago

    So I'll just have a mentos pack that isn't minty. `

  • 0

    Mark Baker

    2 months ago

    the diet coke and mentos doesnt work in the stomach due to antacids IDIOT!

  • 0

    ChaosPowerCP

    3 months ago

    Your stomach acid would dissolve the surface of the mentos almost instantaneously and if you've done the research, you know that the surface is what causes the reaction.

  • 0

    Connor

    3 months ago

    Squirtle

  • 0

    Invisiblelosers

    3 months ago

    Fuck I click the wrong one!

  • 0

    swimmer

    3 months ago

    For both there would be no reaction because the stomach acid would break the first thing down before you start with the second

Load More

Tip: Use the arrow keys to navigate between questions.

Recently Answered

  • You haven't answered any questions yet.

You Rather Mobile

You Rather is available for free on iOS and Android. You're welcome.

For iOS For Android