Add Question

Question Title

Would you rather...

Blue Option
Red Option
 

 

Back to top

Would you rather...

be hung by a noose

be decapitated by a guillotine

Would you rather...

0%
4,436 agree
Be hung by a noose
0%
17,201 disagree
Be decapitated by a guillotine

Execution Methods

added by Patrick
Loading Comments…

26 comments

  • 1

    Brian

    2 years ago

    Really people? I'd want my body to be in one piece at my funeral. Also, I've heard that you live for a few brief moments after getting the guillotine. That would just be freaky.

    • 4

      Ethan

      3 months ago

      If you knew you just died, you would not know how to react to still being alive and wouldn't be able to piece together what just happened. Plus it's instant. I wouldn't want my trachea to shatter and then hang by my neck because the rope wasn't long enough.

    • 2

      noah10105

      3 months ago

      We are almost positive it's instant but the second i die i'm asking Louis XVI

    • 0

      EwanDaBoss

      4 weeks ago

      no cause you could stare at people and mouth to them

  • 0

    Brendan

    2 years ago

    Short and sweet, maybe throw the crowd a wink when they lift your head for dramatic effect. And as South Park stated, if one is hanged their bowels let loose.

  • 0

    _____________

    2 years ago

    Guillotine doesn't have the same connotations of shame as the noose... stupidity, yes, but also revolution, and the Middle Ages!

    • 1

      Alyssa

      4 months ago

      ....they were invented in the late 1700s.......................

  • 0

    ximi

    2 years ago

    You don't actually live anymore after you are decapitated. There are just basic reflexes that will still be executed for a short while after your death. Meaning if your head is held towards the sun after he is cut off you'll still close the eyes. Anyway... I really wouldn't want to shit my pants in the moment I die (this is actually true).

  • 1

    Roze

    2 years ago

    There is always a chance someone will rescue you from the noose. Also, bowels let loose after the guillotine, I believe

  • 2

    Azer Faraclas

    2 years ago

    If they tied the noose wrong you would end up being strangled. I'd rather just lose my head.

  • 0

    rando

    2 years ago

    Noose. At least I would die in a standing position.

  • 0

    SnazziestPants

    1 year ago

    Honestly, there's no good choice here. You can live for a bit after being guillotined, and there are all sorts of things that could go wrong with either, aka having to go again.

    • 0

      Alyssa

      4 months ago

      ... you dont live, ur body just twitches after. And frankly, they just let you strangle to death if your deck doesnt break while being hanged.

  • 0

    PowerRainbows

    1 year ago

    quick and painless

  • 0

    Linkums

    1 year ago

    It's probably illogical, but the guillotine unnerves me.

  • 0

    memodear

    9 months ago

    Hey, you'll get it over with. With a noose, you have a chance of suffocating, instead of just breaking your neck.

  • 0

    ekobor

    7 months ago

    My death of choice (Short of peaceful in the sleep and hit by an ambulance) Also, no matter what killed you, you have a chance of releasing bodily functions. Some people will, some won't (immediately). It is not the type of death that causes it. It depends on how your body reacts to a sudden lack of input, whether it releases the sphincters or not.

  • 0

    luisaswim

    7 months ago

    Decapitation is a whole lot quicker.

  • 0

    betw1xt

    5 months ago

    Just as long as I'm face down.

  • 0

    ThatShawnGuy

    3 months ago

    Guys, fun fact, your head lives for 30 seconds once it is removed. You can still see and feel pain. Whilst being hanged by a noose will result in you having a stroke and near instantaneous death.

  • 0

    Grickel

    3 months ago

    quick

  • 0

    Whatshisface

    3 months ago

    It would be fast and painless. Getting hung is slow and painful, I don't want that...

  • 0

    LoyalJoker

    2 months ago

    Just like Marie Antoinette.

  • 0

    BlooporialDude

    2 months ago

    If you have any upper body strength and they're too stupid to handcuff you, you can just hang on to the rope.

  • 0

    LOLking

    1 week ago

    Instant death...

Tip: Use the arrow keys to navigate between questions.

Recently Answered

You Rather Mobile

You Rather is available for free on iOS and Android. You're welcome.

For iOS For Android