Add Question

Question Title

Would you rather...

Blue Option
Red Option
 

 

Back to top

The zombie horde has just broken into the farmhouse where you six other survivors were hiding., would you rather...

Run upstairs and barricade the second floor

Sequester yourselves in the cellar

The zombie horde has just broken into the farmhouse where you six other survivors were hiding., would you rather...

0%
284,605 agree
Run upstairs and barricade the second floor
0%
110,754 disagree
Sequester yourselves in the cellar

Think fast!

added by Derek
Loading Comments…

You don't have the weapons or numbers to fight your way out.

  • Meta Votes395,359 votes
  • Tags
Unmoderated: This question has not been reviewed by You Rather moderators. Content may be misformatted, offensive or inappropriate in nature.

116 comments

  • 87

    killmenow666

    2 years ago

    with the cellar, there is usually only one way out, while upstairs will probably have windows.

    • 39

      DiamondDigger

      10 months ago

      FALSE: International Residential Code (IRC) 2000 requires accessible egress windows to be built below grade on all modern residential construction.

    • 9

      Bob

      9 months ago

      But the zombies can get in there too!!

    • 5

      Jon

      8 months ago

      what would you do jump off the building and get injured and get eaten anyway

    • 3

      Ben

      8 months ago

      cellars have storm doors.

    • 14

      Pagazz

      8 months ago

      It's simple. You jump out the window to commit suicide rather than getting eaten alive. Also, cellers are dark and if its the apocalypse the power could be completely off :P (simply it would be creepy as hell)

    • 22

      Kris

      6 months ago

      I will piss on all the zombies from upstairs

    • 5

      sam

      6 months ago

      you can also knock them back down the staire

    • 3

      Jesse Taggart

      5 months ago

      @DiamondDigger.... Dude it's a Cellar, Not A Basement

    • 1

      morbidlyobesefrog

      5 months ago

      Clearly the bodies would start to pile up blocking the entrance to the second floor as you would throw things at them... whereas if the bodies pile up in the cellar and the zombies have surrounded the house...

    • 3

      Matthew Lord

      2 months ago

      the second floor isn't that much of a fall, if you're feeling like a bitch, throw a matress out, if not, combat roll bitches

  • 33

    deadtreekid

    2 years ago

    go up the stairs, then destroy them. simple as that.

  • 15

    nowhereman136

    2 years ago

    need i remind you that in "Night of the Living Dead" the only survivor was in the basement. In most cases, the zombies would forget your there and move away.

    • 9

      AkshaySauce

      9 months ago

      Also being underground will mostly if not completely mask your scent. Besides, it doesn't say you can't improvise weapons. Smash some wine bottles or something.

    • 6

      Patrick

      9 months ago

      Was the first survivor of a zombie movie not a black man on the second floor. It is also advised to destroy the stairs in many scenarios. Furthermore, you would have the upper hand

    • 9

      Manuel

      9 months ago

      Maybe, or they could break through the window. But you could probably board it up, if you're fast enough.

    • 0

      Plutters

      3 months ago

      Patrick I agree with your point but what does him being black prove?^

    • 0

      Bane

      2 months ago

      @plutters black people are always the first to die in horror movies

    • 0

      Zombies_Expert

      1 month ago

      A zombie relies on all 5 senses equally. The human smell can linger in an area for quite some time. Even I you had storm doors, you are looking at basic suffocation due to lack of oxygen. Considering you are breathing out carbon-dioxide that is.

    • 0

      IdRather

      1 month ago

      @nowhereman136 being UNDER the zombies would not block your scent and they would most likely not forget you're there. also by that logic if u were upstairs they could also forget you're there @Patrick exactly you could destroy the stairs! and you WOULD have the *upper* hand, literally XD

  • 7

    ExiledNarwal28

    7 months ago

    Computer's upstairs

  • 5

    Brian3

    1 year ago

    higher ground + easier escape.

    • 2

      T.P.N

      1 month ago

      go out of window, then parkour you're way up to the roof.

  • 4

    Seth Attaway

    8 months ago

    Its too circumstantial. I would need to know the configuration of both and what the house was like. Another thing to consider: many people store more food in their cellar than upstairs xD. But I hate being trapped so Imma say upstairs.

  • 4

    projects8an

    2 years ago

    Depends. Do you have guns? From the upstairs you can access the roof, yes? Boom! THAT'S FIVE MOTHERF*@$ER! (Bonus points if you know the reference)

    • 0

      lugal3211

      9 months ago

      It says you don't haven weapons

    • 7

      Jacob Storms

      9 months ago

      But it says you have no weapons

    • 0

      Freq-Sho

      9 months ago

      Lugal and Jacob, Actually! it says you don't the THE weapons to fight your way out it does not say you don't have any weapons. So he could very well have a gun or 12 just not enough to get out of the situation

    • 0

      MrDerp

      8 months ago

      Gears of war, shooting atleast 5 locust when the patrol comes by. That was just hilarious from Marcus

    • 0

      Dajah

      3 months ago

      Actually actually! @Freq-Sho you dont have ANY weapons.

  • 3

    Velatus

    1 year ago

    Having the high ground is a strategical advantage. And you can push them down the stairs, knocking down the rest down too.

  • 3

    CptHomer

    1 year ago

    Gotta get to the high ground + don't want to die eaten by zombies in a low lit cellar

  • 2

    mara

    4 months ago

    hmmm. second floor - surrounded by zombies - to escape youll... jump into the waiting horde? cellar - barricade yourself in - can possibly dig an alternate route out further away from the zombies. also, supplies in the cellar maybe?

  • 3

    overtherainbow

    1 year ago

    Cellar = can dig self out after zombies forget im there.

    • 7

      Joshua Guss

      1 year ago

      Did you see resident evil were the zombie dig through the ground & grabbed the person with its mouth

  • 2

    derp herpington

    8 months ago

    destroy stairs jump out window if necessary

  • 2

    Artico

    9 months ago

    Get on the roof and wait for da choppa

  • 2

    Mthomp18

    9 months ago

    I'd just build a Roman style defense; ditch & mound, possibly put up a palisade. Trapping yourself inside a house would be foolish.

  • 2

    ThatShawnGuy

    1 year ago

    You can always get out the window, or go on the roof if they break in.

  • 2

    Revan

    1 year ago

    Cellars dont have dirt walls they are usually pretty thick with concrete so i doubt you'd be able to dig your way out. Assuming theres a bunch of zombies just in your barn and around the front then at least you could break out of the 2nd floor walls which are made of wood and jump down and run.

  • 1

    Austin2050

    3 months ago

    Cellar may also have food, or at least wine.

  • 0

    Mason

    1 week ago

    If u barricade the door they will eventually get in, but if u hide in the celler they cant get you, but then u would starve to death, so the only thing to do is fight them

  • 1

    Amber Cornish

    5 months ago

    1. Actual zombies probably wouldn't be able to get up stares. 2. If they do, then there is a way out. 3. I rather not be stuck in a basement for days.

  • 1

    Mykol Dorito Harper

    5 months ago

    Upstairs, Xbox is upstairs

  • 1

    gwen

    6 months ago

    The idiot who runs upstairs in horror movies always dies. Always. Plus, the cellar door is made of stone, and there is another door made of steel behind it....and we have a lifetime supply of nutella, cheese, water, vegetables, and various juices down there.

  • 0

    Hiem

    2 weeks ago

    With being down in the cellar, it'd probably be harder for the Zombies to get in there if the door was a trapdoor kind of thing with stairs leading down. They would forget about you after a while and then move along somewhere else, and you could walk out, quietly kill any stragglers with kitchen knives, and then move along, being perfectly fine.

  • 1

    AnalCarniage42069666

    8 months ago

    I am a big fan of Hitler's actions during the second world war.

  • 1

    erushite

    8 months ago

    If you hid in the cellar you'd at least be able to tunnel your way somewhere. Go to the top floor and cut off from everything.

  • 0

    Zuko

    3 weeks ago

    Build a barricade of chairs, start a French Revolution.

  • 1

    Ryan

    9 months ago

    I saw the movie. Ben, the one who stayed upstairs, survived. Well, until he was shot anyway

  • 1

    TheIrishFox

    9 months ago

    Read the Zombie Survival Guide so you don't get in my way as a zombie.

  • 1

    Misael Jimenez

    9 months ago

    Always take the high ground.

  • 0

    Hannes Ott

    4 weeks ago

    If the second floor had a nice computer, a credit card and internet, then no shit blue.

  • 1

    matt

    11 months ago

    I would think the zombies would find the tiny window in the celler

  • 1

    Hannah Mayes Harris

    11 months ago

    Um, I'm thinking you could snipe them from the upstairs windows.

  • 1

    ZymphV2

    1 year ago

    If things took a turn for the worse you could jump, you might break your leg and they'd catch you later but it's better then being cornered and eaten imo. :)

  • 1

    Stian Dahl Sommerset

    1 year ago

    HEIGHT ADVANTAGE

  • 1

    Stian Dahl Sommerset

    1 year ago

    HEIGHT ADVANTAGE

  • 1

    Stian Dahl Sommerset

    1 year ago

    HEIGHT ADVANTAGE

  • 1

    ekociela

    1 year ago

    Has no one seen Revenge of the Sith?

  • 1

    George

    1 year ago

    Doubt zombies would have the intelligence to get into the cellar, Just sit it out a few day and they will forget. And the cellar is probably more sound proof.

  • 1

    Kritz29

    1 year ago

    It would take some time for the zombies to climb up the stairs than tumble down. I'd just wait for them to be outside my door then jump out and run for it. It would be a surefire way to survive.

  • 1

    xMeggieManiacal

    1 year ago

    The cellar is easier to barricade.

  • 0

    Andrew

    1 month ago

    28% of people are gonna die

  • 0

    John Rodack

    1 month ago

    If there were stairs then the zombie would have to organize and go single file or they would be even more slow and could only get in one by one also I could climb down from a farm house easily I don't know if a zombie could climb up it!

  • 0

    Walrus

    1 month ago

    Probability of food tools. Also cellar doors are usually badass

  • 1

    hendrxson

    2 years ago

    um anything is a weapon during the zombie apocolypse but the 2nd floor is better cause you might be able to escape but in the cellar you are fucked

  • 0

    SuperNoodle

    1 month ago

    Cellar is where the wine is at. Drink yourself dead before they get to you

  • 0

    ChaosPowerCP

    2 months ago

    If it's only the second floor and you land right, you could just, jump, land, and be in good enough condition to escape.

  • 0

    Asmith18

    2 months ago

    HAVE YOU GUYS PLAYED BLACK OPS ZOMBIES!?!?!?! THEY GO UP THE FREAKING STAIRS!!!!!

  • 0

    monkeyjoe70

    2 months ago

    dammit i chose the wrong one

  • 0

    Brandon

    2 months ago

    Destroy the stairs

  • 0

    Amdg3x7

    2 months ago

    No place to run if they come into the cellar. On the second floor you could always try and jump out of the window, then at least there is a slim chance you could get away.

  • 0

    BioshockBeast

    3 months ago

    Is it just me who thought of the map farm from blops2?

Load More

Tip: Sign up to see adult-rated questions.

Recently Answered

You Rather Mobile

You Rather is available for free on iOS and Android. You're welcome.

For iOS For Android