Add Question

Question Title

Would you rather...

Blue Option
Red Option
 

 

Back to top

If you could only play one for the rest of your life, would you rather...

Play Rock Band

Play Guitar Hero

If you could only play one for the rest of your life, would you rather...

0%
183,436 agree
Play Rock Band
0%
211,232 disagree
Play Guitar Hero

Rock Band vs. Guitar Hero

added by Stolkmen
Loading Comments…

Which guitar game would you prefer?

Unmoderated: This question has not been reviewed by You Rather moderators. Content may be misformatted, offensive or inappropriate in nature.

68 comments

  • 27

    oxytocin93

    1 year ago

    guitar hero songs suck....i like rock band's songs better...

    • 4

      JNmeister

      9 months ago

      Yeah. Queens of the Stone Age, Faith No More, Nirvana, Queen...

    • 26

      Mark

      9 months ago

      QotSA, Nirvana, and Queen are all in Guitar Hero. -__-

    • 3

      John Gaylor

      7 months ago

      Queen, ACDC, The Who, Nirvana, Metallica are all in Rock Band.

    • 6

      Boomye

      6 months ago

      Rock band sucks.

    • 5

      Steven Rogers

      6 months ago

      All those songs got onto guitar hero AFTER rock band. Let's see what else got onto guitar hero after rock band; -Character customization -Drums -Vocals -Custom songs -Band vs Band -World Touring Campaign. What does guitar hero not have that rock band does? -Real Instruments -3,000+ DLC songs -Keyboard

    • 9

      NigerianNinja

      6 months ago

      They both suck

    • 0

      Mike Buonomo

      3 weeks ago

      @john guitar hero ACDC and guitar hero Metallica. look them up and stare in awe at the stupidity of your comment.

  • 22

    izzy421096

    1 year ago

    I'd rather play a real instrument

    • 3

      snyzzle

      2 months ago

      @NigerianNinja: then why'd u vote?

    • 0

      Jay

      1 month ago

      TIL guitar isn't an instrument.

  • 9

    groovykat

    2 years ago

    you can play guitar hero style as well as others on Rock Band.

  • 7

    alex

    9 months ago

    fuck dj hero

  • 4

    tombomberzorz

    9 months ago

    You can make custom songs in rock band, so, of course I'd choose rock band!

    • 0

      alisox

      5 months ago

      Newer GH games have that feature too.

  • 4

    doubledork

    9 months ago

    guitar hero ftw

  • 3

    Anonymous

    9 months ago

    Guitar Hero > Rock Band. Rock Band is just a Guitar Hero wannabe.

    • 5

      Reed

      8 months ago

      The people who made Rock Band started Guitar Hero, Harmonix made GH1, GH2, and GH:RT80's. Then they sold the license to Neversoft, then Harmonix started making Rock Band.

  • 3

    Kyle

    1 year ago

    Guitar Hero has all the instruments Rock Band does, in case you didn't know. They really should have changed the name by now.

    • 6

      Poptart

      8 months ago

      Guitar hero doesn't have keyboard and pro guitar/bass

  • 3

    nashcali22

    1 year ago

    Theres a guitar on rock band so as far as I'm concerned they are the same thing

  • 2

    lijiah

    8 months ago

    I gave up both when I started playing an actual guitar, but Guitar Hero in general has more metal music.

  • 2

    Mark

    9 months ago

    Songs are better on GH, plus you can use other instruments as well, for those that don't know by now... It's been that way for a few years.

  • 1

    Jopo

    5 months ago

    And Guitar Hero has way more games to suit what kind of songs you like!

  • 1

    DemonicWaffle

    6 months ago

    Rock Band: more realistic. Guitar Hero: more fun

  • 1

    Raz

    8 months ago

    i think it is just the same

  • 0

    Alan Skolkin

    3 weeks ago

    Guitar hero is more of a challenge

  • 1

    Morgan Marie

    11 months ago

    drums!!!

  • 0

    Nikolai0169

    1 month ago

    theres a difference? (never played one himself)

  • 1

    ImprovShoes

    1 year ago

    Yeah, Rock Band has better songs.

  • 0

    Ras

    1 month ago

    rock band rocks

  • 0

    metalhead4740

    2 months ago

    Guitar Hero Metallica. That is all.

  • 0

    nia Alair

    2 months ago

    I don't wanna be lonely I need people lol

  • 0

    Divinity

    2 months ago

    same shit idrc

  • 0

    Fabrizio_

    2 months ago

    what's the difference

  • 0

    Barbie Chanelle

    2 months ago

    I dont play either

  • 0

    Yykba

    3 months ago

    i'll just play Rocksmith with my dean c250 thank you very much...

  • 0

    Zachary

    3 months ago

    I prefer Lego rock band but this is fine too

  • 0

    esnide

    3 months ago

    i'd rather just play my real guitar

  • 0

    Jopo

    5 months ago

    Guitar Hero is original! Plus it has everything that Rock Band has!

  • 0

    alisox

    5 months ago

    I'm laughing at most of the comments because everyone is like "Rock Band has this" and "Guitar Hero has that" when in reality they have a lot of the same features...

  • 0

    fr0st

    5 months ago

    Why dont we have both?!

    • 1

      alisox

      5 months ago

      Because we're playing would you rather here and the point is that you have to choose one?

  • 0

    Monsteize

    5 months ago

    Rock band because they introduced being able to have more than a Guitar!

  • 0

    Kyle Jacob-Harry Gamble

    6 months ago

    Makes me sick. Rock Band IS the shit.

  • 0

    KatieKinz

    6 months ago

    On Rockband you can also play the lower part of the guitar (which I find alot easier)

  • 0

    JumpinJac

    6 months ago

    I don't play either

  • 0

    sparta_the_cat

    7 months ago

    guitar hero has more games, better songs, guitar hero metallica anyone? and i find the rockband guitars are too stiff for the buttons, guitar hero has looser buttons plus guitar hero has memorable characters that are in every game. i have only had on rock band game and my life and it never worked for me, not the right stuff for me to enjoy it

  • 0

    MrBeaches

    7 months ago

    More people can play Rock Band, considering that they are the earlier games and not the newer, crappier GH games

  • 0

    Olivier Thavonekham

    7 months ago

    Guitar Hero is dead.

  • 0

    Albert Bro Pold

    7 months ago

    I cab play with more friends

  • 0

    Purdy31

    8 months ago

    Rockband has much better songs!

  • 0

    neonblue120

    8 months ago

    I prefer RB drums and rocksmith over them all.

  • 0

    Olivia BeepBoop Evan

    8 months ago

    or learn a real instrument?

  • 0

    Ruben Garcia

    8 months ago

    you can by loads of songs for rock band and add them to your library. Rock Band>Guitar Hero

  • 0

    Jamie

    8 months ago

    To be honest, Id rather play a real instrument.

  • 0

    Ultimoz

    8 months ago

    Rock Band > Guitar Hero, Rock Band do band specialised versions i.e Green day rock up AC/DC rock band, beatles rock band

    • 1

      Dolan

      8 months ago

      Guitar Hero did that first with Aerosmith. Just saying..

  • 0

    Shamble

    8 months ago

    Considering the following: It's really easy to get custom songs of pretty much EVERY song ever released on Guitar Hero for Rock Band. Fully working and fully animated with instruments added to previously guitar-only songs. The Pro Guitar/Bass and Keyboard instruments. The absolutely MASSIVE Rock Band DLC library. The fact that Guitar Hero has been discontinued and Rock Band hasn't. Yeah. Rock Band, definitely Rock Band.

  • 0

    Caroline Q

    8 months ago

    Rockband has many instraments you can choose from to play

  • 0

    Ryanar

    8 months ago

    Rock Band has way more songs than Guitar Hero.

  • 0

    Anog92

    8 months ago

    Rock Band has better songs.. Guitar Hero has that rocker feel to it... Excellent Songs > Rocker feel

  • 0

    GetPwned

    9 months ago

    rock band virtually has guitar hero in it, and you can play it with your friends

  • 0

    Cobalt Smith

    9 months ago

    ROCK BAND!!! Much larger selection. :D

Load More

Tip: Use the arrow keys to navigate between questions.

Recently Answered

  • You haven't answered any questions yet.

You Rather Mobile

You Rather is available for free on iOS and Android. You're welcome.

For iOS For Android