Add Question

Question Title

Would you rather...

Blue Option
Red Option
 

 

Back to top

If you and a sibling are kidnapped, would you rather...

Live and let your sibling die

Die to save your sibling

If you and a sibling are kidnapped, would you rather...

0%
115,755 agree
Live and let your sibling die
0%
291,059 disagree
Die to save your sibling

Life or Sacrifice

added by r3dsparcl3
Loading Comments…
  • Meta Votes406,814 votes
  • Tags
Unmoderated: This question has not been reviewed by You Rather moderators. Content may be misformatted, offensive or inappropriate in nature.

237 comments

  • 121

    supdalat

    1 year ago

    ONLY CHILD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • 56

    jezemondo

    1 year ago

    I think that really most people would lie about this

    • 6

      Sopwafel

      8 months ago

      Why lie? no1 knows you would let your sibling lie if you press a button.

    • 11

      Mario Zul

      8 months ago

      I'd rather die than live a completely fucked up life.

    • 3

      Jamie Stewart

      2 months ago

      if my brother was in danger there is literally nothing anyone could do to stop me from saving him even if i died in the process

  • 31

    p01arb33r

    1 year ago

    red means you lied or fail at evolution

    • 41

      Grickel

      1 year ago

      No it means you have moral

    • 13

      woohoo

      7 months ago

      no it means you have a heart

    • 8

      Johan Leth Gregersen

      6 months ago

      It's just so easy to say in theory, but evolution and with you being human and all, your instincts is going to drag you towards blue. This is not a fairy tale, not a disney movie, you'd save yourself any day.

    • 5

      mohamed

      5 months ago

      I'm guessing none of you know anything about how altruism is a positive evolutionary trait, especially to close relatives, since you and your sibling share DNA! evolution is about surviving as a species rather than an individual, so what might seem stupid to an individual it might save a species. that's why ants for example are much more successful in nature than most insects, because they have complex hierarchical systems with soldiers who don't get to mate and die a lot.

    • 3

      myfate2022

      5 months ago

      anyone in the red obviously doesnt understand how easy it is to stand on that moral high ground until you're actually faced with death. the number one goal of all life on earth is SURVIVE!

    • 3

      showerbro

      5 months ago

      Johan, why do you automatically assume that everyone would be as selfish as you? there are many stories of people in really life (not fairy tales) sacrificing themselves to save others. So no, not everyone would save themselves any day

    • 0

      Becky Barnes

      4 months ago

      it means your not a lying bitch

    • 0

      Dajah

      3 months ago

      Actually, it means you might just have a soul, morals, a conscience, or maybe *le gasp* a heart ??

    • 1

      Joosep Puusaag

      3 months ago

      I am just a heartles monster :)

    • 0

      Thither

      2 months ago

      Not really a failure. You're saving half of your DNA

    • 0

      Nick

      2 months ago

      I would feel terrible for the rest of my life, but if it really came down to life or death I think all of us would choose to live.

    • 1

      Ólafur97

      1 month ago

      I am a twin and I would do anything to save my brother.

    • 0

      Kcela

      1 month ago

      Joosep Puusaag at least you admit it, you are the best of the blue

    • 1

      IAmDoneHere

      1 month ago

      Calm your balls, this is a HYPOTHETICAL situation, and despite what you think you might do, in the face of the choice you may well chose differently.

  • 19

    EcksNine

    1 year ago

    My desire to live supersedes my love for my brother.

  • 11

    Firewave

    9 months ago

    I love how everyone is commenting "Liars" just to make them feel better. Not to be a complete douche, but i know a lot of people who would (if they could) give their life for a sibling that might die. And obviously if my brother were to get cancer or a deadly disease, if i had the option to sacrifice myself to cure him; no doubt in my mind I would

    • 0

      pleaseimbeyonce

      5 months ago

      That first sentence, you're so right. I would give up my life for a sibling, well I have 3 and I'd definitely for 2 of them.

  • 10

    fireknight

    1 year ago

    At least i be a hero

    • 4

      xXOrangutanXx

      1 year ago

      You'd be a hero? For what dying? That don't make you a hero son.

    • 17

      Jacob

      9 months ago

      And now I see why your name is Orangutan. If someone died for me, yeah, they'd be my hero. I don't know what makes someone a hero in your eyes, maybe a bright cape and lasers or something...

  • 8

    Jacob

    9 months ago

    I'm fine with all of you people who value yourselves more than your siblings, but don't assume that the rest of us are incapable of valuing someone else's life above our own just because you don't know what it's like to have someone that important in your life. My sister isn't the only one I'd die for, either.

  • 7

    Unoriginal_1

    9 months ago

    I felt like such an asshole when i saw the results

  • 6

    Ashley

    8 months ago

    Pretty sure the ones who picked blue are accusing all the reds of being liars because they feel guilty they would pick their own life. And so are trying to make everyone else feel just as bad. :)

  • 6

    xeo

    1 year ago

    I already decided that if one of my siblings and I had a limited portion of food that was running out and there was only enough for one person, I'd give it to them. Screw me being selfish, I will never want to see my sibling die. (2nd youngest out of 7 and I've learned more about life than half of my high school..)

    • 1

      Jack

      8 months ago

      Wow you're so moral and enlightened. Is that why you would rather punch a toddler than be punched yourself? (referencing a wyr you answered)

    • 1

      pleaseimbeyonce

      5 months ago

      ^ You're a douchebag you know that?

  • 6

    thisisjane

    1 year ago

    Oh God forbid seeing someone means everything to you die...Trust me no one wants that.

    • 9

      Hobson Liabunya

      9 months ago

      But they'll watch you die, I'd simply say we should both try to save ourselves it's not selfish it's human,whoever dies dies

    • 1

      Hobson Liabunya

      9 months ago

      But they'll watch you die, I'd simply say we should both try to save ourselves it's not selfish it's human,whoever dies dies

    • 3

      Xyon Martinez

      9 months ago

      Well not all siblings mean the world to us now, do they?

    • 3

      Xyon Martinez

      9 months ago

      Well not all siblings mean the world to us now, do they?

  • 5

    JanCarlo

    1 year ago

    Liars, you fucks would save yourselves. I know I would.

    • 2

      Dajah

      3 months ago

      Bitch, please proceed to killyourself. What reason would anyone have to lie for ? Its not like any of us know each other IRL. Maybe some people just have morals, a guilty conscience, a heart ?

    • 1

      Kcela

      1 month ago

      or the thing that makes humans what we are, sentient.

  • 4

    Andrew

    8 months ago

    wow, 70% of people lied...

    • 1

      Dajah

      3 months ago

      Bitch, please proceed to killyourself. What reason would anyone have to lie for ? Its not like any of us know each other IRL. Maybe some people just have morals, a guilty conscience, a heart ?

  • 4

    steveoh!

    8 months ago

    Okay, everyone who chose "red" stop acting like you're all angels and we're the bad guys. Nothing and I mean NOTHING is greater than the human will to live. Not even love, and yes i do have a sibling who I love dearly, so I'm speaking with experience. And stop pretending like you all are so sure and conviced you would do it.

    • 1

      Dajah

      3 months ago

      Your right, I hate to say. But me personally, I have a very guilt conscience, I couldn't forgive myself. Not to mention I was just raised from a young age to always protect my siblings, younger or older..

    • 0

      Kcela

      1 month ago

      have you not heard of sentience the thing that separates humans and the average animal? We have feelings and knowledge of the world around us, unlike most other species. So i'm guessing that you must be some sub species that can't feel or think of the world that they live in

  • 4

    Zay

    9 months ago

    Feel like most blue people would either have a bad relationship with their siblings or are only children. It's hard to imagine, saving yourself over helping your sibling, when you've never had that love. That, or you know your sibling would never do the same, so fuck it. LOL. just my take on it.

  • 4

    MiniCale

    1 year ago

    I would live and hunt the guy who kidnapped us down and kill him

  • 4

    Coolkid1256

    1 year ago

    I REALLY hate my brothers...

  • 1

    chelsea_xoxo

    4 weeks ago

    I hate my brother...

  • 3

    atfinals

    1 year ago

    I've seen Ray, that shit messes you up forever.

    • 0

      valduck17

      9 months ago

      That drug addiction definitely makes those "visions" 10x worse and 10x longer than ever would be

    • 0

      Lebron

      4 months ago

      Yup

    • 2

      XxxxBlack.Veil.BridesxxxX

      2 months ago

      if i lost a close family member i would kill myself aswell, no point losing two of us

  • 2

    T.P.N

    6 months ago

    id chop my own dick of for my bro

    • 0

      Dajah

      3 months ago

      Uhhh...I don't don't even have one and I wouldnt do that shit.

  • 2

    Capps

    9 months ago

    Don't care much for my siblings.

  • 2

    Hobson Liabunya

    9 months ago

    If you die, your sibling is gonna blame himself for your death, end up using meth,crack to deal with it and die in a flat in Liverpool, not a good life

    • 0

      Kcela

      1 month ago

      ......WHAT THE FUCK? That was blown way out of proportion

  • 2

    Collin

    9 months ago

    Lets all be honest here...

  • 2

    OmegaApple

    9 months ago

    72% of people are lying on the interwebs

    • 0

      Dajah

      3 months ago

      Please proceed to kill yourself. What reason would anyone have to lie for ? Its not like any of us know each other IRL. Maybe some people just have morals, a guilty conscience, a heart ?

  • 2

    reno

    9 months ago

    people who are red are liars dont act like you are a sefless person becuase im sure we all know if it came down to it you would let your sibling die unless ur somekind of freaking suicidal freak honestly people be honest with yourselfs!!!!!111

    • 6

      ToxicDreams

      9 months ago

      Not everyone is selfish. I would rather die than see my baby sister die.

    • 0

      wtfduud

      5 months ago

      @Toxic, give me all your money then, come on, I need your money, don't be selfish.

    • 1

      showerbro

      5 months ago

      @wtfduud, you have no right to his money, a sibling has a right to live.

    • 0

      Dajah

      3 months ago

      @wtfduud Please proceed to kill yourself. What reason would anyone have to lie for ? Its not like any of us know each other IRL. Maybe some people just have morals, a guilty conscience, a heart ?

  • 2

    Corey

    10 months ago

    Hmm interesting. 75% of people on this website are liars.

    • 0

      Dajah

      3 months ago

      Please proceed to kill yourself. What reason would anyone have to lie for ? Its not like any of us know each other IRL. Maybe some people just have morals, a guilty conscience, a heart ?

  • 2

    Alex Janisse

    11 months ago

    17,000 people are liars.

    • 0

      Dajah

      3 months ago

      Please proceed to kill yourself. What reason would anyone have to lie for ? Its not like any of us know each other IRL. Maybe some people just have morals, a guilty conscience, a heart ?

  • 0

    daniel

    2 days ago

    they are pain in the arses !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • 0

    chase

    2 days ago

    72% of people are lying

  • 2

    Leon8455

    1 year ago

    I thrive to live, its human nature to live sooo, yeah I like living.

  • 0

    shaszbotter

    1 week ago

    you can get a new one (know it sounds rude)

  • 1

    SamFishon

    4 months ago

    I have kids my siblings don't. easy choice.

  • 1

    Clark Kent

    5 months ago

    because I have a heart

  • 1

    Xidas

    5 months ago

    Fuck morals, I follow my instinct to survive.

  • 1

    Triton

    5 months ago

    I couldn't possibly live without my brother.

  • 0

    lanzadam

    2 weeks ago

    Siblings are annoying easy choice

  • 1

    myles

    6 months ago

    i may hate them but their still family. i would risk my life for them.

  • 0

    Ang

    2 weeks ago

    My brother is a little shit. but he's my little shit

  • 1

    Steph

    6 months ago

    and watch her die, slowly~

  • 1

    jmanaterjose

    7 months ago

    Damn my good instincts

  • 1

    DZ1074

    8 months ago

    I don't care if I'm known as a coward, idiot, loser, or wimp, I'm not dying.

  • 1

    jackson

    8 months ago

    i hate my brother so much

  • 1

    Rebekah Jean Waykedr

    8 months ago

    Depends on the sibling

  • 1

    Eddy Martinez

    8 months ago

    I will save both of us

  • 0

    Katie Crosley

    3 weeks ago

    Was there really any question? Even though my siblings drive me crazy, I value their lives above my own.

  • 0

    Amir Sadegh Rassouli

    3 weeks ago

    It depends on who the sibling is!

  • 1

    Madi60517

    9 months ago

    I wouldn't be able to live it down if I sacrificed family...

  • 1

    Six1Cynic

    9 months ago

    Im an only child

  • 1

    valduck17

    9 months ago

    I just don't like/know/or see him that much. Tough break Bro

  • 0

    Dipper Pines

    4 weeks ago

    She's only 3 months

Load More

Tip: Use the arrow keys to navigate between questions.

Recently Answered

You Rather Mobile

You Rather is available for free on iOS and Android. You're welcome.

For iOS For Android