You would not die or be severely injured either way, and all of you would get along nicely. The shows referenced are Doctor Who and Supernatural
Unmoderated: This question has not been reviewed by You Rather moderators. Content may be misformatted, offensive or inappropriate in nature.
Add Comment
151 comments
Tip: Sign up to see adult-rated questions.
Recently Answered
- You haven't answered any questions yet.
fred
People would rather live with ghosts and demons than the Doctor? WHO?
Foop
Well hav eyou ever seen suprnatural? Damn, I would do anything just to get near Misha Collins....And he's not even a main character.
Nat
I see what you did there.
Alejandro J Quintani
would be friend of both guys, cracking stupid manly jokes with dean and chatting with sam
DrAvvesome13
I see what you did there Also I completely agree
Stormtra
But I don't wanna die. ;-;
Xerun
But after a while I would have to leave the Doctor and live with Rory for eternity in a hotel room. Sign me up for the Impala :D
Jaxquel Deyran Delacruz
I WOULD BITCH
Amira
Dean Winchester is a sexy man.. I'd hit that with holy water ;) mmm lmao
ZoSo
That was probably the hardest decision I've ever made.
Bjor69
With the TARDIS, I could go visit the Supernatural universe when ever.
Emalee Bennett
Monsters, Desmond and ghosts? Plus two hot men? Sign me up(;
Emalee Bennett
Demon* stupid auto correct
Foop
I'd do it for Misha...Gah, an dhe's totally adorable because he doesn't understand much.
Cave Johnson
Live a life as a hot ginger? sign me up!
Alejandro J Quintani
i would crack jokes with dean an chat with sam, while we travel in an asm car slaying demons and monters? and i get payed from tieme to time, FUck yeah
Leah Tedesco
The Doctor and Rory are two hot men.
CyborgKittenPoweh
DESMOND THE MOON BEAR!
Fullitenhund
Are you kidding me? The only downside is Weeping Angels. The upside? Be able to live everything from Big Bang to the end of the Universe. Also, DALEKS!
ThelastCenturion
the Angels aren't even scary. it's all about those nanogenes o.o
Fullitenhund
But with nanogenes comes Captain Jack freaking Harkness! :D
fgim62
HEY ASSBUTT . . . supernatural is better
Fullitenhund
fgim62: Doctor Who:8.7 @ IMDb. Supernatural: 8.6 @ IMDb.
Cartoonboy
Pfft. Weeping angles at least are nicer than Daleks. They at least give you a change to live (albeit a life in the past)
AlabamaSlim
I see what you did there fgim62 when Castiel throw the holy molotov on Lucifer and says "Hey ASS BUTT!
Michael James C
If you have the chance to become a Companion, you BECOME A COMPANION
Brian
You made me choose, you terrible person!
Erika Rose Prince
Be with the Winchesters, Castiel and the Impala? Oh hell yeah. ;P Also, I don't like Amy Pond or the 11th Doctor... XD
Jennifer
can not believe I just chose between my 2 favorite shows, but it has been done :/
Jose Luis Zaragoza
exactly how i feel haha it was a hard choice but supernatural wins cause tha'ts been my favorite show longer
ShayaMary
Seriously the hardest question I've ever had to answer. Dean and Sam though, of course.
n7soldier
How is there even a debate? THE IMPALA, GUISE.
Cartoonboy
*Disagree
Molly
How IS there even a debate? THE TARDIS, GUISE.
Becquerel
HOW COULD YOU MAKE ME CHOOSE?????? No one's really sure how much TIME Amy will actually spend with the Doctor in-universe, but for all intents and purposes I'm assuming she isn't around for much longer than the other companions. So Supernatural shenanigans it is, then. For maximum time spent being with badass fighting mofos. Also Metallicar.
janelle
With Amy's life, you get the Doctor, and Rory.
Eric Frandemo
So you mean to tell me if I got to choose between being crammed in the back on an awesome Impala sweating my ass off killing monsters, Demons and ghosts... Or... Being in a one of a kind TARDIS, with a Mad Man and still fight off monsters, demons, ghosts, cybermen, weeping angels AND Daleks (and much more) using space and time as your friend? Well thats a pretty easy choice.
Pranav Arya
Easy.
Za'chary Westbrook
And yet, you chose wrong.
Eli Zane Kimmel-gray
SUPERNATURAL!
tmanwater
Dean is sexy as hell.
B Tyler Margison
Well, for those where looks is what matters, the Doctor changes appearance every so often. So if you don't like the one you got now, wait a little while. Also, the Doctor's usually British, so if you're attracted to men, I would imagine that would be a plus? Also, TARDIS and sonic screwdriver totally won this for me. Sam and Dean are cool, but c'mon, they're always dealing with their brother/family shit. You'd be left out half the time.
IsNotShort
All of space and time at your hands to view and explore. This is a very obvious choice.
Aly Randomuscus
this was the hardest decision i've ever made
Ory
Saving people, hunting things, the family business! Hell yeah
Christi
I sat in front of my computer, staring at it, for like half an hour before answering this. I would die to be in the TARDIS, but hot damn, have you seen Jensen Ackles?! That is one fine man right there!
Lexi
ALLONS-Y!!
Molly
Too bad Amy wasn't with Ten.
FurstinChaos
That was quite possibly the most painful decision of my life. I only managed to choose by reasoning that, when the Doctor and I inevitably would go our separate ways like the companions always do, I'd "break his heart" as he's said and I know I'd constantly miss him.
Molly
No, you'd break his hearts. Two hearts, as it is the way of the Timelords to have two hearts.
Jessica Brown
I think I lost a part of my soul on this one.
Nathan Waitforit Grandinette
I'd do anything to just drive that impala...
FalloutBoy
Why doesn't the first one have 90% of the votes
LordTetris
I'm not even sorry.
Tim
Sexy time with 10
Chrissi
11. 10 was Tennant.
Aaron Edenfield
All about supernatural man!
some jewish dude
get high, see which one is better...
Anders Holmenlund Mi
man can't i have both
Ayla Bray
Hardest question ever. Travel time and space see anything any where at any point in time, or travel the us with two super sexy men. Solving crime, saving lives. So Hard to answer
Skipper
Have you seen doctor who?
Émie Sirois
SUPERNATURAL *-*
Abbie Rachel Donovan
ARE YOU TRYING TO KILL ME. seriously. my two favourite shows.
CyborgKittenPoweh
people....rather live....WITH EVIL DEMONS AND CRAP INSTEAD OF THE DOCTOR?! okay...WHAT. just...WHAT.
qwerty123
Fuck that supernatural mumbo jumbo, I want to see the stars!
SeparateWay
Ahh, but I hate Amy Pond!
Jaxquel Deyran Delacruz
I CAN'T BELIVE THAT IT'S A 50/50%
Jaxquel Deyran Delacruz
I WOULD KKILL ANY ONE IN MY WAY THAT WILL TRY AND STOP ME FROM SAM AND DEAN.
riley
Are you fucking kidding me. There is no competition.
Mr. Zero Falk
Can I just say that the fact that right now this is 50/50 makes it all the more epic? I'm a huge fan of both series, but I'm sorry, as much as being a Hunter with freaking Sam and Dean would be AWESOME, the experiences are pretty harsh and, let's face it, they have trained for all their lives, any one of us wouldn't last two missions with them. Besides the chances of being sent to hell or tortured by Crowley are pretty big. I'd rather see EVERYTHING on a Spaceship which also happens to be a Time Machine with the most incredible person in the universe living adventures where being clever counts more than being strong and well-trained, seeing the most beautiful places of reality and contemplating creation rather than only seeing demons and deaths; see the birth of stars, and, while it WOULD be risky, I'd have someone that has more knowledge than nearly anything and a freaking time machine to rescue me. The Winchesters are amazing, but in the end, they're only human. The best damn humans in the world, but humans nonetheless. So, Allons-y I say!
malacia
love both shows but i don't want to limit my life to amy's with the doc, I wouldn't be limited to just 2-3 seasons. and castiel which is reason enough.
DJCass92
Doubt me and the winchesters would get along fine. Those 2 fight 24/7.
Courtney Elizabeth
I feel like if I were Amy Pond with the Doctor I would get more heartbroken than I would with Sam and Dean. All the feels man I just can't..
memes_ru1
DOCTOR WHO FTW
Celia McAlpine
SAM AND DEAN... yum. Just... just yum.
RT9999
Nice cars, guns and demon hunting, be bros with the Winchesters, with pretty good looking girls all over, and you ask like its a hard question, you silly, silly individual.
StarswirlTheBearded
I don't even know what the red one is.
ThatDumbKidPipes
I like both shows a lot but... Jared Padalecki that man is gorgeous
Chrissi
Hot ginger, Matt Smith, that hot as hell accent and married to a Roman centurian? Fuck yeah.