Or sign in with You Rather account
Forgot password? · Create Account
Or create a You Rather account
Already have an account? Sign In
Would you rather...
We moderate all questions to prevent duplicates, offensive grammar, and laziness.
Back to top
be a character in Lord of the Rings
be a character in Harry Potter
wtf is wrong with you ppl
wtf is wrong with UguiSE I mean come on guiSE
you could be an ordinary-skilled character while in the harry potter unierse if you're a common wizard it's still the shit
wait...Gabora...you can still be a regular human...
Gabora, you could end up being Dudley or equivalent. That'd suck.
So? you wouldn't have a choice in the matter I presume. you can't choose what you would be born as. besides, there's no wartime danger and thousands dying but there's still action and adventure along with girls! (or guys!). You get to use magic too.
Black Riders, Nazguls, Orcs, Goblins, Middle Earth, Hobbits, The Shire, Better Magic, Trolls, and Dwarfs over Teenage, newbie wizards, some bald guy with no nose, weak trolls, wands are the only weapons, and its a school?
FUCK THAT SHIT
I'd rather use magic at home then in middle earth.
Gandolf would kick Dumbledore's ass
Can we choose which character? If so, I choose Gandalf.
MAGIC, or swords?
Theres Magic in Lord of the rings too....
dont hate me ive never seen lord of the rings but i did see the hobbit
Hardest decision of my life. I swear. I love LotR, but my childhood was Harry Potter. Sorry
harry potter is a fag
boo your face
AVADA KEDAVRA! To you as well.
A much bigger chance of dying in lotr.
Shut up! Colloportus!
I wouldn't say he's a fag, but I do love LOTR
Well, he IS homosexual, and the slang, albeit much more rude, term for homosexual is "fag."
THx for taking my answer xD
Lord of the rings os the best story of all time
Middle Earth is too dangerous and filled with doom for my tastes.
But there are a bunch of wizards that could turn evil at any moment and just murder everyone. XD Also, what if you had to be a muggle? D=
The likelihood of death is significantly lower in Lord of the Rings, I think. J.K. Rowling's writing just reads "I don't even give a crap anymore" later on.
I love LOTR, but I dont wanna be an orc... and everybody in HP world's a wizard
Not true. First you have Muggles, non magical humans. Then you have giants, trolls, centaurs, pixies, dememtors, mer people, ghosts, hippogriffs, dragons, phoenix's, Goblins, house elves, and a whole list of other creatures.
why don't u be an elf, man, dwarf, hobbit, or wizard???
Filch is a squib. He can't do magic.
Hobbits? There is more to middle earth then orc's
you could still be a wizard
A lot of stupid people
I'd be a Hobbit living in the Shire in peace. And then a random fucking wizard smokin' pot would come and take me to an adventure^^.
WHAAAAA?!?! IT'S ALL ABOUT MIDDLE EARTH!!!!!
what's wrong with 222, 638 people? I mean, a sword can cut a wand into pieces... and if you'd get to be an elf, you'd be immortal, extremely beautiful, with awesome senses and everything... what is a hundred times better than going to some lame school for lame teen wizards.
Wtf. 62% Harry Potter? You're telling me you're gonna miss out on those epic battles just to be a wizard? :o
You assholes disappoint me.
Thinking of my love for food, tobacco, beer, parties and the fact that I am very short, I'd probably be a hobbit, and how cool isn't that? And even if I didn't end up as a hobbit, it'd still be cool because I'm in fucking Middle-earth.
Im Going With Lord Of The Rings
But your username is... Harry potter...
D: NO ONE should hate on lord of the rings
One does not simply kill Voldemort by going back in time with Hermines time traveling watch.
I see what you did there.
cmon ppl HOBBITS ARE CUTE!
WTF? Lord of the Rings is an epic fantasy classic! HP nerds...
I just think the adventure that comes with LOTR would be way more fun. Id be slayin some bitches.
Sauron or Gandalf! (Or Frodo because of the ring.)
You're all unworthy of Middle Earth & you're not welcome here. P.S. Who yu think taught Dumbledore how to comb his long beards, eh??
who the hell needs magic when you have epic fighting skills?
I cannot believe lord of the rings was beaten by harry potter. This is an outrage
I think Lord of the Rings is better and more exciting than Harry Potter.
Well you Harry potter fans have fun attending wizard school while I kill orcs and smash down beers with gandalf
LOTR is at least cool. Harry potter fucking sucks. And LOTR has Boromir
One does not simply hate LOTR.
Being magical and British accents.....guys it doesn't get better than that aha
What the hell is wrong with you
THOU SHALL NOT PASS THIS COMMENT
This makes me extremely sad. Harry Potter wasn't even very good and Lord of the Rings is awesome.
I am surprised and disappointed at the number of people who betrayed the LOTR. Harry Potter has to thank J.R.R Tolkien for so many of the things it emulated from wonderful middle earth! ...Sorry for the Nerd rage guys.
Someone needs to Avada Kedavra all against harry potter
be a derp who can do magic, and only when holding a stick....or be a badass sword-wielding troll-killer.....Also, Lord of the Rings has more class.
i would try and walk into mordor
As much as I like Harry Potter...
In Harry Potter Maybe You will be Noone just a cilivian who can't learn magic and doesn't know it exist but in LOTR you can be whatever you can be a Hobbit Archer
If I Chop Your hands off yo cannot use your fancy magic
Use magic powers to transport yourself into LOTR.
For those idiot harry potter fans (not all are) who think u cant be a wizzard, take moment to remember gandalf, sauramun, or even radagast!!! Plus, those wizzards cant die!!!!
This is the biggest bullshit I have ever seen!!!!
Hmmm, entire mythical land to explore and have adventures, or castle to live at and do magic for half the year then head back to your boring existence?
Lord of the rings is epic Harry potter is meh
Tip: Sign up to see adult-rated questions.
You Rather is available for free on iOS and Android. You're welcome.
312,925,224 votes collected
You Rather is a project of One Mighty Roar © 2013