Add Question

Question Title

Would you rather...

Blue Option
Red Option
 

 

Back to top

Would you rather...

kill a 5 year old girl's puppy

kill old lady's cat

Would you rather...

0%
94,278 agree
Kill a 5 year old girl's puppy
0%
220,066 disagree
Kill old lady's cat

A Girl's Pet

added by Madison
Loading Comments…

If it was the 5 year old she would cry like all day but might get a new one when the 55 year old why would most likey die of sadess or something idk :P

Unmoderated: This question has not been reviewed by You Rather moderators. Content may be misformatted, offensive or inappropriate in nature.

183 comments

  • 77

    Petar Bajakov

    10 months ago

    Who the hell writes this shtuff anyway?!

    • 15

      Madison

      10 months ago

      Well sorry i got bored so i posted this

    • 75

      xdpher

      9 months ago

      I would MAKE the little girl watch me kill her puppy, and then I would rape the dead, lifeless carcass as if it was goat on rufes. I would then tie the little girl to a chair, clipping her eyelids off so she can't blink, and then make her watch me go to town on her grandmother. I would then kill the old lady's cat. Seeing how the old lady would die of sadness, I would wait 5 minutes so that there is a cold, wrinkly, lifeless corpse on the floor. I would then commence the necrophilia. After I am done raping the grandmother's lifeless body, I would then grind up the girl's parents, after kidnapping them, into a fine powder, mix it up with chili, and then force feed it down the child's throat. I would then cut each of her fingers off, one-by-one, until she has a 5 bloody stubs on each hand. I would then take off my pants and then force her to jerk me off and then I would then shove my cock into the child's mouth, gagging her, and then suffocating her. Her struggling got me off. I would then tie a weight to her foot, and drop her off the side of a nearby bridge, into a river, so that I can watch her struggle to stay aloft. That was the best day of my life. @Petar Bajakov lol I do :D

    • 37

      xdpher

      9 months ago

      oh gawd, please delete my comment? I think Im going to be sick... :{

    • 31

      xdpher

      9 months ago

      yeah, my brother got on, sorry everybody that was scarred by this :(

    • 16

      Conrad

      9 months ago

      bull fucking crap the my brother got on my account excuse bull

    • 19

      leghead

      9 months ago

      @xdpher i dont think i laughed that much at your comment ever.

    • 12

      Dragonite

      9 months ago

      I would kill the girl's dog. The cat doesn't bark its ass off while I try to sleep.

    • 6

      nikkie

      8 months ago

      Is there a way to report someone's post? Some people post the worst, most immature garbage on here.

    • 1

      7Devon7

      7 months ago

      I agree with xdpher. ill join him

    • 2

      Jacob Dittmer

      7 months ago

      The girl would get over it. Barely has a memory anyway.

    • 1

      o0AHK0o

      6 months ago

      a cat has 9 lives

    • 1

      Shaco Clone

      1 month ago

      @xdpher i do believe you need a new hobby or if you are right your brother needs to get a new hobby

    • 0

      Shaco Clone

      1 month ago

      BECAUSE THAT IS MY JOB

    • 0

      Nicholas Howland

      1 week ago

      @xdpher I laughed. Alot. my sides hurt

    • 0

      doubledice235

      3 days ago

      @xdpher shes going to bite your cock in half.

  • 43

    Austin Ward

    10 months ago

    I like watching children's dream crushed, and their eyes fill with the tears of broken joy. This is why I became a teacher.

    • 8

      Mackenzee Hemming

      10 months ago

      i love you ._.

    • 2

      JohnnySins

      9 months ago

      shut up mackenzie.

    • 1

      Evelyn Ayala

      9 months ago

      U are bogus AF I also love breaking hopes and and telling kids "YOU ARE WRONG AND I'M RIGHT BECAUSE I'M BIG AND YOUR SMALL MUAHAHAHA" just makes me happy \(^~^)/

    • 1

      dawson

      1 month ago

      the 5 year old wouldn't maul me to death

  • 9

    Nobodee

    10 months ago

    The lady might die. better scar than kill

    • 0

      Katelyn Stimpson

      6 months ago

      But if you scarred the kid, she might kill herself later anyway because of the experience, plus the old lady probably won't remember she had a cat anyway lol.

    • 1

      FreezingFire

      2 months ago

      Katelyn it says she DIES of fucking sorrow, thats fuckin sad man

  • 9

    NipponKota

    10 months ago

    The old lady has lived her life anyway. I'd rather not scar the child.

    • 8

      Jessej1996

      9 months ago

      Plus she's probably got like 30 more.

    • 6

      ossmosse

      8 months ago

      What the, this cat is the only thing the old lady probably has left. All of her friends are probably dead or about to bit the dust. I'd kill the child's dog, A, to leave the elderly a peace before she passed away and B, teach the girl about loss. No one lieks a spoilt brat.

  • 4

    Kyle

    9 months ago

    Kill the puppy. She'll forget about it after two weeks. It would ruin the old women.

  • 3

    YouAreAPeasant

    9 months ago

    Depends on the kid, really. If the kid has been through shit, like abuse and stuff then no. If she's an annoying brat, then that I'll kill the peasant's dog right in front of her.

  • 3

    Jen O'Malley Dorr

    9 months ago

    You guys think 55 is an old lady??

  • 3

    Spassomonkey $_$

    9 months ago

    The old lady might not have any other friends/family that can be with her all the time

  • 1

    Filipp Pöyhönen

    1 month ago

    Meh, I hate dogs for some reason that I for some reason don't know why.

  • 2

    TheLolzMaster

    6 months ago

    I hate kids, plus I like cats more

  • 2

    xXxLegitFallenAngelsxXx

    6 months ago

    I don't like dogs .______. Plus killing a cat would break my heart.

  • 1

    Hana Sulayman

    1 month ago

    A 5 year old girl could always get a new dog :/

  • 2

    B.K

    7 months ago

    I hate dogs you can hate now!!!

  • 2

    Matthew

    9 months ago

    CATS FUCKING SUCK DIE YOU FUCKING ASSHOLE!

  • 2

    Eridan Ampora

    9 months ago

    puppies are adorable cats are little shits

  • 2

    katelynb13

    9 months ago

    The old lady would probably beat me up with her cane or something

  • 2

    ButtsMcgee

    9 months ago

    I hate cats anyways

  • 2

    LOLking

    9 months ago

    I could never kill a puppy in my life

  • 0

    pedro

    2 days ago

    just get her another cat. probably she won't notice the difference

  • 0

    PinkyWinkle

    5 days ago

    Hate Cats.....easy choice

  • 0

    Malvolja

    6 days ago

    Teaches the kid to grow up.

  • 0

    Prem Patel

    1 week ago

    She's old..I Bet she won't even know it

  • 0

    palkia684

    2 weeks ago

    I hate dogs... and cats... and basically every other pet with fur.

  • 0

    Mephiste

    2 weeks ago

    She can get another one, The Old Lady's cat is probably her only friend and the friend she'll keep until the day she dies, You guys are so fucking stupid.

  • 0

    krom

    2 weeks ago

    Life is full of disappointments kid...get over it...

  • 1

    Pedrodarigan

    8 months ago

    The old lady probably has, like, 408 more of them

  • 0

    Daniel Didnot Kilpatrick

    3 weeks ago

    Well some one hates people

  • 1

    Xela

    8 months ago

    i couldn't kill a puppy!

  • 1

    Mordecaithebro Kugle

    9 months ago

    Reall

  • 0

    wow-assissin

    3 weeks ago

    kill the puppy, teach the kid that something you love can be brutaly taken away, shes young, she will adapt, besides, shes 5, like she gives a shit in 2-5 days

  • 1

    Robbot

    9 months ago

    I hate cats...

  • 1

    Sölvi Snær Jökuls

    9 months ago

    i dont like cats so...

  • 1

    Lachlan

    9 months ago

    couldn't handle the guilt of a child

  • 1

    Mewsi

    9 months ago

    Obviously both.

  • 1

    Mewsi

    9 months ago

    Obviously both.

  • 1

    May

    9 months ago

    because I hate cats

    • 1

      FreezingFire

      2 months ago

      So you'd rather have the old lady die than just hurt a little kid a bit

  • 1

    Vesko

    10 months ago

    Cats are less smart, so killing one would be a lesser loss than killing a dog. Still both are horrible, and not because of the pet owners, but because of the pets themselves.

    • 10

      neighborly

      9 months ago

      Yeah, I'm sorry, but you don't know what you're talking about. Just because cats have their own agenda and did not evolve as pack animals it does not mean they're less intelligent. Try picking up some books on the subject before spewing more drivel out into the world.

    • 3

      JoeyBonzo

      9 months ago

      You're a fucking moron, although I personally prefer dogs over cats, cats are proven to be more intelligent but just dont showcase every single thing they do

    • 0

      weirdo

      9 months ago

      JoeyBonzo, You are wrong as cats aren't "proven" to be smarter than dogs. IN ANY STUDY.

    • 0

      nikkie

      8 months ago

      To everyone who replied to Vesko...since he is entitled to his opinion just as you all are, I have to say....WHO CARES??

    • 0

      Vesko

      8 months ago

      @neighborly @JoeyBonzo Are you kidding?! Dogs are clearly smarter than cats, just as humans are smarter than monkeys. It is a scientific fact. Stating that "cats have their own agenda" doesn't help your theory any more than sending me to read books and studies, which don't exist.

    • 0

      FreezingFire

      2 months ago

      I think and old lady + a cat is much smarter than a little fucking puppy

  • 0

    Dave

    1 month ago

    Fuck cats

  • 0

    Rezhwan Amanj

    1 month ago

    Sorry, Ma'am, I just happened to run over your cat with my truck

  • 0

    jozilla

    1 month ago

    I hate cats -.-

  • 0

    Martin Karoliussen B

    2 months ago

    She won't be sad for very long...

  • 0

    RandomPerson1337

    2 months ago

    I'm so sorry. Its just... I dunno. FUCK YOU Madison

  • 0

    warriordude

    2 months ago

    fuck the blue ones dogs are loyal and smart cats are bitches

  • 0

    Franklin Chen

    2 months ago

    FIND FRIEEEENDS!!!

  • 0

    Morbid Mist

    3 months ago

    I hate children and dogs so it's like killing two birds with one stone. \\//‿⊙

  • 0

    MarcusORLY

    3 months ago

    Cats are awesome. Fuck dogs

  • 0

    John

    3 months ago

    The old lady will forget it sooner and probably pass on soon too. The girl will remember that all her life

  • 0

    Tyler Conwell

    3 months ago

    Why does a 5 year old girl own a puppy in the first place? She'd be just as happy with a stuffed-animal puppy.

  • 0

    nigg

    3 months ago

    lol i want to watch the reaction

  • 0

    Caoilfhinn

    3 months ago

    The girl could be too young to remember the puppy after a few months... some old ladies are attached to their cats on a scale that when the cat dies they die quickly afterward.

Load More

Tip: Sign up to see adult-rated questions.

Recently Answered

You Rather Mobile

You Rather is available for free on iOS and Android. You're welcome.

For iOS For Android